"Stan Getz was once
asked his idea of the perfect tenor saxophone soloist. His answer was, 'My
technique, Al Cohn's ideas, and Zoot's time.”
- Gene Lees
Harry Allen may
well be the fulfillment of Getz’s recipe for making the perfect tenor saxophone
soloist. His style of playing certainly recaptures the essence of the ultra
cool sound and the easy, lyrical phrasing of Stan, Al and Zoot.
For as Richard
Morton and Brian Cook state in their Penguin Guide to Jazz on CD 6th
Ed.:
“Allen has been
acclaimed by an audience waiting for the Four Brothers to come back, if not the
big bands. His full-blooded tenor sound offers countless tugs of the forelock
to Zoot, Lester, Hawkins and whichever other standard-issue swing tenor one can
think of; and it's hardly surprising that these enjoyable records have been
given the kind of approbation that was heaped on the early Scott Hamilton
albums. Allen plays nothing but standards, delivers them with a confidence and
luxuriance that belie his then twenty-something age, and generally acts as if
Coltrane and Coleman had never appeared at all.”
The editors go on
the describe Allen’s “steamrollering sense of swing and his sewing of phrases
and licks together with the kind of assurance once associated with Zoot Sims.”
Harry Allen can
play and he comes to play.
He’s a throwback
to a time when tenor saxophonists “plugged in” a rhythm section, planted their
feet and “stretched out” into solos that were marked by fleet intensity, a warm,
breathy sound and boppish licks.
Harry’s approach
to the tenor saxophone finds the melodious aspects of the instrument and brings
them to the forefront: no upper register squeaking; no running of seemingly mindless
chromatic scales up and down the horn; no lengthy extrapolations that cause the
listener to “head for the door” or to “turn that damn noise off.”
Harry’s music
makes you stop and listen; it makes you feel good; it makes you smile. Here is
the wonder and beauty of music the way The Muses, who created it, meant it to
be played.
As is the case
with many, younger musicians these days, Harry has his own website on which you
can locate lots of information about his background, schedule of performances
and a discography.
And here’s a link
to a feature about Harry that Stephen Fratallone posted to his Jazz
Connection Magazinein
September 2005 entitled Just Wild About
Harry: Harry Allen brings His Swinging
Mainstream Tenor Back to Jazz’s Forefront that’s just loader with good
stuff about Harry.
Given his affinity
for the style of playing made famous by the late tenor saxophonists Zoot Sims
and Al Cohn, fittingly, these days, Harry can often be found in the company of
guitar Joe Cohn, Al’s son. The two have formed a quartet that frequently
records and appears at Jazz festivals and clubs both at home and abroad.
One of our
favorite recordings by Harry and Joe in accompaniment is Eu Não Quero Dançar –
I Won’t Dance [RCA Victor 74321 58126-2] about which Richard Cook and Brian
Morton commented:
“For a change of
pace, Allen did a sort of bossa nova album in I Won't Dance- sort of,
because he swings it a lot harder than Getz chose to. Instead of the melodies
billowing off balmy breezes, there's the odd tropical storm along the way, and
it's an agreeable variation on what might have been expected.”
I have selected No More Blues [Chega de Saudade] from
this CD as the audio track to the following video tribute to Harry. Checkout
the simultaneous soloing by Harry and Joe that begins at 2:55 minutes. Beautifully done and not easy to
do without tripping over one another’s solos.
A performance by Clare's Big Band of his original composition Miles Behind. The solos are by Warne Marsh on tenor saxophone and Conte Candoli on trumpet. Larry Bunker is on drums.
Born in Vicksburg, Mississippi in 1910 and relocated to Chicago by his family at the close of World War I
in 1918, it seems that bassist Milt Hinton had been around Jazz since its
beginnings.
But like Osie
Johnson, his drumming counterpart on numerous recordings sessions over the
years, I found it difficult to locate much information about Milt despite the
fact that the Lord Discography lists him on 1,205 recording sessions!
So when my copy of
Down
Beat: The Great Jazz Interviews a 75th Anniversary Anthology arrived
from Santa Claus this year, I was thrilled to discover that it contained Larry
Birnbaum’s detailed essay about Milt entitled Milt Hinton: The Judge Holds Court, January 25, 1979.
Here are some
excerpts that primarily focus on Milt’s nearly 16 year association with the Cab
Calloway Orchestra.
I think you’ll
find it to be a wonderful reminiscence of what the world of Jazz and the United States were like for a working musician from
approximately 1935-1950.
"Bass means
bottom. It means foundation, and bass players realize that their first job j is
to support the musicians and the ensemble. Bass players know more about
sharing ffld appreciating one another than any other musicians. In all my years
I have never heard a bass player put another bass player down; they have great
love for each other and they learn from one another and they share experiences
and even jobs. It's why the art of bass playing has made more progress in the
last 40 years than the art of any other instrument."
Milt Hinton should
know. At 68 [Milt died on December 19, 2000 at the age of 90], the dean of American
bassists stands at the summit of a half-century career that has taken him from
the speakeasies of Chicago to the pinnacle of the big-band era with Cab
Calloway to the jam sessions at Minton's in the early days of bop. …
"But to get
back, in '35 Cab went to California to do a movie with Al Jolson called The Singing Kid. His bass player, Al
Morgan, was a fantastic visual player. He was really my idol; I used to watch
him just to see how a great bass player acted, and that's what I figured I
would be like when I grew up—of course I'm nothing like that at all. When they
made this movie, the cameras would be grinding away and every time Cab looked
around, instead of the camera being on him it would be on Al Morgan, because he
was a tall, black, handsome guy and he smiled and twirled his bass as he
played. This got under Cab's skin because it was a little too competitive for
him. But nothing happened about it until one of the producers said to Al Morgan,
'Look, you're so very photogenic that if you were going to be around here,
every time we made a picture with a band scene in it you would get the job.' So
this guy quit Cab in California and joined Les Kite's band with Lionel Hampton and all
those guys who were established in Hollywood, and he stayed there.
"Cab started
back east without a bass player, and my friend Johnson told Cab that if he was
going through Chicago he should stop at the Three Deuces and dig Milt Hinton. By this
time Simpson's band had broke up and the owner had opened a Three Deuces at State
and Lake. Zutty Singleton was the bandleader and
Art Tatum was the relief piano player there. When Art played, it was my
responsibility to stand by and come in for his finale. He played solo piano,
but for his last tune, which would be something up-tempo, I was supposed to
join him and take it out and then come on with Zutty's band. Of course, Art
Tatum was so fabulous that I don't think I ever caught up to him; his changes
were too fast for me and he left me standing at the post. But it was such a joy
to see him, and he was a very nice person. He could see slightly if you put a
very bright light behind his eye, so during intermissions we played pinochle
together.
"Zutty had
the band, mostly New Orleans guys. It was Zutty playing drums, Lee Collins, a great
trumpet player whose wife recently put out a book about him; there was a kid
from New
Jersey, Cozy Cole's brother, who played piano, and Everett Barksdale was
the guitar player. We worked for months at the Three Deuces and my acceptance
as a musician was established, because Chicago was a New Orleans town—all the
jazz was New Orleans jazz—and Zutty Singleton was the drummer. There was Baby
Dodds and Tubby Hall, but Zutty was really the guy. He had been with the Louis
Armstrong Hot Five, with Earl Hines and Lil and Preston Jackson, who is now
living in New
Orleans. Zutty finally decided to take me into his rhythm section. Now I
was with the king and now I was established as a top bass player in Chicago.
"And now Cab
comes down and he listens to me play. He never said a word tc me, he just sat
there—I saw him in the room—and a guy said, 'Cab is in.' He came in with a big
coonskin coat and a derby and, man, he was sharp, people were like applauding.
He sat at a table and listened to us play, and on the intermission he invited
Zutty over to the table to have a drink with him—not me, but Zutty. He said,
'Hey, I'd like that bass player, I heard he's pretty good.' Zutty was most
beautiful and kind to me and he was only too happy to have me make some progress,
and he said, 'You can have him,' in that long drawl, New Orleans accent he had. So Cab said, 'Well, thanks
man, and if you ever get to New York and there's anything I can ever do for
you, you just let me know,' and they shook hands. Then Zutty came upstairs— I'm
playing pinochle with Art Tatum—and said, 'Well, kid, you're gone.' 'Where am I
going, Zutty?' 'Cab just asked me for you and I told him he could have you.' I
said, 'Don't I have to give you some kind of a two-week notice or something?'
and Zutty said, 'If you don't get your black ass out of here this evening, I'll
shoot you.'
"Cab finally
comes up and sings a song with us, he hi-de-ho's and breaks up the house—and as
he's leaving he says to me, 'Kid, the train leaves from LaSalle Street Station
at 9 o'clock in the morning. Be on it.' That's all he said to me, no discussion
of salary or anything. I dashed to the phone, called my mom, and told her to
pack that other suit I had and my extra shirt. I got my stuff—of course, there
was no time to sleep—and I met the band at the station. It was quite an
experience, because I had never been on a train except coming from Mississippi to Chicago, and you know I didn't come on a Pullman or any first-class train—we were right
next to the engine. I'd never seen a Pullman in my life, and here all of these big-time
musicians were on this train, on their own Pullman.
"There were
these fabulous musicians: Doc Cheatham, the trumpet player; Mouse Randolph,
another trumpet player; Foots Thomas, the straw boss, the assistant leader of
the band, a saxophone player; Andy Brown, a saxophone player; and the drummer,
Leroy Maxey. These guys had been working in the Cotton Club in New York and they were really professional: Lammar
Wright was another great trumpet player in the band; Claude Jones, a great
friend of Tommy Dorsey's, was the trombone player; and there was my old friend
Keg Johnson who had recommended me.
"I must have
looked pretty bad. I had the seedy suit on, a little green gabardine jacket
with vents in the sleeves—we called them bi-swings in those days. Keg was
introducing me around, and the great Ben Webster was in the band. He and Cab
had been out drinking that night and they missed the train at LaSalle Street, but you could catch the train at the 63rd Street station. They were out on the South Side
balling away with some chicks and they didn't have time to come downtown. So
they picked up the train at 63rd Street and got on just terribly drunk. I was
sitting there and Keg was trying to introduce me to the guys, and Ben Webster
walks in terribly stoned and he looked at me—I must have weighed 115 pounds
soaking wet— and said, 'What is this?' and Cab said, 'This is the new bass
player,' and Ben said, 'The new what!?' I remember thinking I would never like
Ben, and he turned out to be one of my dearest friends.
"I hadn't
asked anybody about the price, but I was making $35 a week with Zutty at the
Three Deuces and that was one of the best jobs in town. Fletcher Henderson was
at the Grand Terrace at that time with Roy Eldridge, Coleman Hawkins and ChuBerry and they were making 35 bucks a week. I
didn't know how to approach anybody about money with Cab, so finally I told Keg
that Cab hadn't said anything to me about money. Keg [Johnson, a trombonist]
said, 'Oh, everybody here makes $100 a week.' Well, I almost fainted—$100 I had
never heard of; it was a fantastic amount of money. This is before Social
Security—they only took out $1 for union dues and you got $99, and $99 in those
days was like $9,000 today. Honestly, you could get a good room for $7 a week;
you could get a fantastic meal for 50 cents and cigarettes for 10 to 15 cents a
pack; bread was 5 cents a loaf; so you can imagine what the thing was like.
"Cab told me
after we started making one-night stands that he was only hiring me until he
got to New
York
and got a good bass player. I was quite happy even to do that for 100 bucks a
week. We made one-nighters for three months before we hit New York, all through Iowa—Des Moines, Sioux City, everyplace, and I got a chance to really
get set and all the guys liked me.
"Well, Al
Morgan was not a reading man. He had been in the band so long he had memorized
the book, so there was no bass book. And here I was quite academic—I'd studied
violin and I'd studied bass legitimately with a bass player from the Chicago
Civic Opera and I never had a problem with reading—I was playing Mendelssohn's
Concerto in E-minor so there was no problem. I said, 'Where's the music?' and
there was no music, so Benny Payne, the piano player, said, 'You just cock your
ear and listen, and I'll call off the changes to you.'
"Benny was
most kind and we've had many laughs about this later; I'm about S'7" and
Al Morgan was a tall man, he must have been 6'3". There was no time to get
new uniforms so I had to wear his clothes, and when I put on his coat I was
just drowning in it. His arms were much longer than mine so that you couldn't
see my hands because they didn't come out through the sleeves. The guys said I
looked like Ichabod Crane or somebody—I'm playing bass through the coat-sleeves
and they were laughing.
"I had never
really played with a big band of that caliber, and when they hit it that first
night it almost frightened me to death. The black guys in those days used to
wear their hair in a pompadour—it was long in front and we would plaster it
down with grease and comb it back and it would stay down. Of course, when it
got hot that grease melted and our hair would stand straight up. I had this big
coat on and I got to playing and the grease ran all out of my hair and my hair
was standing up all over my head and Benny Payne is calling out these chords to
me—'B-flat! C! F!' The guys in the band told me later that they were just
rolling with laughter, they could hardly contain themselves, because I was
really playing good but I looked so ungodly funny.
"Finally Cab
saw that the guys liked me and we were having so much fun that he said, 'We'll
give him a blood test.' There was a special tune that Al Morgan did, featuring
a bass solo, called 'The Reefer Man.' Cab said, 'OK—"The Reefer
Man,'" and my eyes got big as saucers because I didn't know anything about
this new music. I said, 'How does it go?' Benny Payne said, 'You start it,' and
I said, 'What!?' He said, 'We'll give you the tempo but it just starts with the
bass—just get into the key of F.'
I tell you, I
started playing F, I chromaticized F, I squared F, I cubed F, I played F every
conceivable way, and they just let me go on for five or 10 minutes, alone,
playing this bass, slapping the bass, and doing all this on this F chord.
Finally Cab brought the band in with a 'two... three... four' and they played
the arrangement. Benny's calling off the chords to me, and after three or four
minutes the whole band lays out and Benny says, 'Now you've got it alone
again,' and here I go back into this F. I must have played five or 10 minutes,
and Benny comes over and says, 'Now you just act like you've fainted and just
fall right back and I'll catch you,' and I did it and it was quite a sensation
as far as the public was concerned, and the musicians were just out of their
skulls they were laughing so.
"By the time
we got to New York, Ben Webster liked me and Claude Jones liked me and the
guys all said, 'This guy's going to make it,' so I was in. I stayed with the
band 16 years, until 1951.”
It was very
difficult to select among Milt numerous recordings for an example of his bass
work until I came across the following one-slide “videos” from guitarist Billy
Bauer’s Verve Plectrist CD [314 517 060-2] which features Milt’s playing on When It’s Sleepy Time Down South, Lullaby of
the Leaves, and Maybe It’s Because [I Love You Too Much].
Joining guitarist
Bauer and Milt are Andrew Ackers on piano and, who else, but Osie Johnson on
drums.
I always keep a
copy of William Zinsser’s On Writing Well by the computer when
I’m writing.
You never know,
one day I might – write something well [“Hope springs eternal?”].
In his chapter
entitled Writing About People – The
Interview, Mr. Zinsser urges prospective writers to:
“Get people
talking. Learn to ask questions that will elicit answers about what is most
interesting or vivid in their lives. Nothing so animates writing as someone
telling what he thinks or what he does—in his own words.
His own words will
always be better than your words, even if you are the most elegant stylist in
the land. They carry the inflection of his speaking voice and the
idiosyncrasies of how he puts a sentence together. They contain the
regionalisms of his conversation and the lingo of his trade. They convey his
enthusiasms. This is a person talking to the reader directly, not through the
filter of a writer. As soon as a writer steps in, everyone else's experience
becomes secondhand.
Therefore learn
how to conduct an interview. Whatever form of nonfiction you write, it will
come alive in proportion to the number of ‘quotes’ you can weave into it as you
go along.”
It seems that
Frank Alkyer and Ed Enright have taken Mr. Zinsser advice to heart, for in
searching for a format to celebrate the 75th anniversary of Down
Beat, they have chosen to edit a collection of interviews that were
published in the magazine from 1934 – 2009.
The interviews are
grouped according to decades and represent, the editors words, “… 124 of the
best interviews or artist-written articles that this magazine has ever produced.”
In the book’s Preface, editors Alkyer and Enright go
on to say:
“The history of Down
Beat is the history of the last 75 years, just told through the lens of
jazz and blues musicians as well as the journalists who cover them. Race
relations, sexual equality, unionism, wars, recessions, birth, life, death, the
triumph of the will, the battle of the soul: it spills across the pages of Down Beat.
But the aspect of
this dense history that holds up best, that truly endures, is the voice of the
artist. The editors of Down Beat get a lot of opportunities
to go back and look through the archives for research. It's one of the great
privileges of working for the magazine, and one of the real occupational
hazards. Plan for an hour of research, then lose the better part of the day
reading through all of those terrific pages from bygone eras.”
Whenever I have an
opportunity to go into the archives, the items that really draw my attention
are the articles written by musicians, or those heavily spiced with quotes
from musicians. The music criticism in Down Beat is fantastic, second to
none, an essential guide to music that is being made. Record and concert
reviews provide a glimpse into how a piece of music is received at the time
it's presented. The critics may not always be right, but they do give you a sense
of how that work fit into the critic's personal tastes as well as into the
realm of other music being created at that time.
But the
opportunity to read about Ellington, Armstrong, Miles, Bird, Dizzy, Coltrane,
Brubeck, Eldridge, Lester Young, Ella, Lady Day—all the greats—to hear them
talk about their lives and their careers—in their voices— that's what paints a
lasting picture, and delivers a glimpse inside the artist's world. That's the
essence of Down Beat. …”
So not only does
this 340 compilation contain interviews with musicians, but it also has a bevy
of articles in which musicians in essence “interview” themselves by writing
about their music.
In order to
provide you with a sampling of what’s on offer in this terrific book, here are
excerpts drawn from interviews and guest artist essays for each of Down
Beat’s almost eight decades of publication.
The 1930s – “Duke Ellington: A Black Genius
in a White Man’s World” – Carl Cons
“Duke is highly
imaginative and extremely
sensitive to close and weirdly beautiful harmonies. He has a mirror type of
mind that catches all the brilliant, colorful and vivid images of living and
reflects them in tonal pictures. He is
reflective rather than interpretive in that he is interested principally in
reproducing all of his experiences rather than accounting for them. He is a
tone painter who tries to catch all the warmth and color of a setting sun on
his canvas keyboard, translating sight into sound, and using chords as his
pigments.
Many critics read
a great deal of their own personalities into Duke's music when they start
interpreting it for us—and usually miss the central idea. This is regrettable,
but a simple mistake that would not be made over and over again if they understood
one fundamental characteristic of the Duke. He is a narrator, and a describer.
"Lightnin"' is the description of a train journey with all the
excitement and variety of scenes and sounds. "Mood Indigo" is an innocent
little girl longing—soliloquizing. "Toodleo," the picture of an old
Negro man broken down with hard work in the field coming up a road at sunset,
his broken walk in rhythm.” [p.5]
The 1940s – “Lester Young: Pres Talks About
Himself, Copycats” – Pat Harris
"The trouble
with most musicians today is that they are copycats. Of course, you have to
start playing like someone else. You have a model, or a teacher, and you learn
all that he can show you. But then you start playing for yourself. Show them
that you're an individual. And I can count those who are doing that today on
the fingers of one hand."
It was the Pres
talking. Lester Young, a pioneer of the "new" jazz, whose friends
find themselves in the peculiar position of trying to persuade him to tolerate
the majority of musicians who can't meet his standards, and, on the other hand,
getting others to try and understand the Pres.
"Lester Young
has been so misunderstood, underestimated, and generally shoved around,"
one of them said, "that he almost was pushed out of the field of top
active jazz musicians." The tendency is to relegate him to the position of
a historical "influence."
"If I do a
multiple-tape," Lennie said slowly with determination, "I don't feel
I'm a phony thereby Take the 'Turkish Mambo.' There is no way I could do it so
that I could get the rhythms to go together the way I feel them. And as for
playing on top of a tape of a rhythm section, that is only second-best
admittedly. I'd rather do it 'live,' but this was the best substitute for what
I wanted.
"If people
want to think I speeded up the piano on 'East Thirty-Second' and 'Line Up,' I
don't care. What I care about is that the result sounded good to me. I can't
otherwise get that kind of balance on my piano because the section of the piano
I was playing on is too similar to the bass sound. That's especially so on the
piano I use because it's a big piano and the bass sound is very heavy. But,
again, my point is that it's the music that matters."
One of the
objections voiced to these particular tracks was that whatever Lennie did to
the tape made his playing very fast. "It's really not that fast,
though," Lennie said. There are lots of recordings out there that are much
faster. … The tempo, in most Jazz joints, in fact, is faster than on the
record. And the record was a little above A-flat. That may account for a little
of the speed, too.”
The 1960s – “The Resurgence of Stan Getz” –
Leonard Feather
“Bill Coss,
reviewing his Village Vanguard re-debut in the June 8, 1961, Down-Beat,
synthesized the problems that Getz had to face: "There were in attendance
the haters, musical and otherwise, who came to find out whether the young white
man, who had long ago lengthened the legendary and unorthodox Lester Young line
into something of his own, could stand up against what is, in current jazz, at
least a revolution from it (or a revulsion about it)."
While asserting
that in his own view Getz could and did and seemed as if he always would
measure up, Coss added that "the still broad-shouldered, blue-eyed,
bland-faced young man met musicians backstage, and they tried him with words
and with Indian-hold handshakes of questionable peace and unquestionable war.
The young man out front was his arrogant best, holding his audiences with
strong quotations from his past and much stronger assertions of his version of
the newest (but much older) sound!"
Clearly implied
were the facts of jazz life that had come into focus during Getz's absence: the
cool sound and the cool attitude had given way, during those two or three
years, to a concern for heavy, aggressive statement, to an atmosphere of
racial hostility without precedent in jazz, to an accent on musical anger and
disregard for fundamentals—characteristics that were not to be found in the
light lyricism of a Stan Getz solo.”
The 1970s – “Cannonball The Communicator” –
Chris Albertson
“Critic John S. Wilson summed it up in a 1961 issue of Down
Beat :
‘Cannonball’s
[Julian “Cannonball” Adderley] unique ability to talk with an audience with
intelligence, civility and wit does a great deal toward establishing a warm,
receptive atmosphere for his group.’
The new Adderley
Quintet was born on the Riverside label, whose driving force was the late Bill
Grauer, an enterprising man who greeted the sounds of King Oliver’s Creole Jazz
Band and a new Quincy Jones Orchestra with equal, boyish enthusiasm. In
Cannonball's music, Grauer saw earthy elements that were missing in the
so-called cool jazz and the free-form music that Ornette Coleman was
pioneering— Cannonball's music had soul.
Just how the term
"soul jazz" came about is uncertain. Cannonball believes it was
coined by Grauer, and it might well have been. Certainly, Grauer did a great
deal to promote the use of the term, to the point where its application became
so widespread that it lost any meaning it might have had.
Today the term
"soul" has a different connotation, having become a synonym for
"black." Today's soul music is that performed by the Temptations,
James Brown or Gladys Knight and the Pips. "Let's say that soul has
developed the way it should have, according to Bill Grauer's concept and the
way I thought it was going to be," says Cannonball. "It has developed
along the lines of the old things, utilizing elements of contemporary beats and
stuff like that... now the blues, the same old blues that we loved 25 or 30
years ago. It's a big thing and it's called 'soul' music instead of the
blues... B.B. King is a lion after so many years of being just B.B. King, and I
think it's beautiful."
The 1980s – “Maynard Ferguson: Rocky Road
to Fame and Fortune” – Lee Underwood
“Ferguson: I always have that fun thing with
composers and arrangers. I say, ' Are you sure what my thing is?' As soon as
they say, 'Yeah, I know what your thing is,' I say, 'Great. Now do something
different.' That is, something which is me, but which I don't impose on other
people.
Basie, for
example, has sounded the same for many years, and yet I can still sit in front
of that band and thrill to it. The same thing with Ellington, even with his
great creativity. The same thing with the Beatles. I refer only to their
validity. I have no interest in talking about the things that don't enhance me.
Their music is their right, their privilege, their art. …
Ferguson: I love the independence of if I never have another hit
single, we're still gonna burn it out every night and we know we'll have good
albums. I enjoy doing my own thing and being contemporary, and doing it
honestly. I really enjoy playing "Rocky," and if you listen to it,
you'll see that, in person, my solos are not the same, and the drummer doesn't
play it the same way.”
The 1990s – “Joe Henderson: The Sound That
Launched 1,000 Horns” – Michael Bourne
“He's not
Pres-like [Lester Young] or Bird-like [Charlie Parker], not 'Trane-ish [John
Coltrane] or Newk-ish [Sonny Rollins]. None of the stylistic adjectives so
convenient for critics work for tenor saxist Joe Henderson. It's evident he's
listened to the greats: to Lester Young, Charlie Parker, John Coltrane, Sonny
Rollins—to them and all the others he's enjoyed. But he doesn't play like them,
doesn't sound like them. Joe Henderson is a master, and, like the greats,
unique.
When he came along
in the '60s, jazz was happening every which way, from mainstream and
avant-garde to blues, rock and then some, and everything that was happening he
played. Henderson's saxophone became a Triton's horn and
transformed the music, whatever the style, whatever the groove, into himself.
And he's no different (or, really, always different) today. There's no
"typical" Joe Henderson album, and every solo is, like the soloist,
original and unusual, thoughtful and always from the heart.
“I think playing
the tenor saxophone is what I’m supposed to be doing on this planet,” says Joe
Henderson. “We all have to do something. I play the saxophone. It’s the best
way I know that I can make the largest number of people happy and get myself
the largest amount of happiness.””
The 2000s – “Dave
Brubeck: That Old Cowboy” – David French
"If you knew
all the guys who never say anything too good about me who secretly know I
opened the door for them, or have said it, but it isn't picked up by the jazz
police," he said. "If I told you all the guys you'd be surprised. At
the same time the critics are saying I'm not playing jazz, I'm influencing a
whole bunch of guys who play so great.
"I'll give
you one example," he continued. "One of my favorite piano players
was Bill Evans. When he was young, he made a lot of good remarks about me. In
the fake book, he gets credit for recording 'Alice in Wonderland' and 'Someday My Prince Come.'
But where did Bill
hear it? Maybe five years before? I know where he heard it, he knows where he
heard it and he would tell me where he heard it. But it dies right there.
"I won't name
any more. But look at some of the best, far-out guys, you'll find that the guy
they heard who set them off in right direction was that old cowboy Dave Brubeck."
Most authors will
tell you that their writings, in whatever form, benefit immensely from the
involvement, assistance and guidance of a good editor.
My late friend, Jack Tracy, joined Down Beat in 1949 and was
its editor from 1953-1958. According to John McDonough in his August/2011
tribute to Jack, “Tracy guided Down Beat out of the last phrases of its fabled but fading
antiquity into a modern era of serious criticism and journalism.”
Upon his passing
in December, 2010, I put together this video tribute to Jack and thought I
reprise it as a fitting way to close this review of Down Beat: The Great Jazz Interviews a 75th Anniversary
Anthology.
The audio track is
vibraphonist Victor Feldman performing his original composition Too Blue with Scott LaFaro on bass and
Stan Levey on drums.
We will have more to say about Max Ionata's latest CD's on Matteo Pagano's Via Veneto Jazz label - Kind of Trio and Dieci - in a future review, but in the meantime, we thought you might enjoy listening to this rendering of The Love Theme from The New Cinema Paradiso by the tenor saxophonist who is joined by Reuben Rogers on bass and Clarence Penn on drums. After Reuben's marvelous introduction, Max kicks in the melody at 1:29 minutes. Beautiful music, beautifully played. Gotta love the young dudes that are carrying on the Tradition.
While preparing a
forthcoming feature on Down Beat Magazine’s 75th
Anniversary Interviews, the editorial staff at JazzProfiles suddenly
remembered that it had been the recipient of an LP album given to all of the
magazine’s subscribers in celebration of it having reached the quarter-century
markin 1959.
“Recorded in Hollywood and New York in special cooperation with Verve Records under
the personal supervision of Norman Granz,” the LP which is entitled Down
Beat’s Hall of Fame Volume 1 [Verve MG V-8320] is comprised of 12
tracks selected by the editors “… to get a full representation of the past
quarter century in Jazz…. [the magazine was founded in 1934]”
Featured artists
include vocalist Ella Fitzgerald, drummer Gene Krupa, tenor saxophonist Coleman
Hawkins with trumpeter Roy Eldridge, pianist Oscar Peterson with bassist Ray
Brown, vocalist Anita O’Day, pianist Art Tatum, tenor saxophonist Stan Getz,
the Count Basie Band, drummer Louie Bellson, tenor saxophonist Lester Young and
alto saxophonist Johnny Hodges and his orchestra.
As we were unable
to find a CD reissue of this recording, we thought it might be fun to make
available the liner notes from the original LP with their point-in-time
reference to the state of Jazz in 1959. We wonder if our old friend, the late Jack Tracy, may have been one of “the editors” who
had a hand in writing them?
These notes are
followed by a video which uses graphics from the LP’s cover art as developed by
the crackerjack production team at CerraJazz LTD and the Magic track from the album played by the Basie band.
If all the greats
in the history of jazz were laid end to end, you'd have . . . something similar
to this LP. Released to help Down Beat celebrate its 25th Anniversary, it is a
disc that attempts to achieve that kind of jazz universality.
Of course, it
would be impossible to get a full representation of the past quarter century in
jazz on five LPs, much less one. How many important figures you have to leave
out, how many great choruses go unincluded!
How, for example, do
you chose between a track by Dizzy Gillespie and one by Charlie Parker?
You take into
consideration that Bird is gone, and will make no more recordings —while the
giant Diz is alive and swinging. That simplifies the task considerably . . .
Or take another
example: the task of selecting someone to represent the mainstream of jazz
drumming. Who should it be? Jo Jones, Buddy Rich, the late Dave Tough, Shelly Manne? In the end, it has to
be Gene Krupa. Go back, if you can, to the old Krupa band recording of No Name
Jive and listen how Gene builds the band unbelievably, while never losing sight
of the basic roll with which he started out. Krupa has always had and still has
a sense of form and clarity of pattern that any drummer alive can learn from.
All things passed through Gene: he was the gatherer of what went before and the
harbinger of what was to come. Therefore, it had to be Krupa . . .
In a sense,
therefore, though the selection of material for this disc was difficult, most
choices had a certain inevitability. These are the selections:
SIDE A
YOUR RED WAGON —
Ella Fitzgerald, with Lou Levy, piano; Max Bennett, bass; Gus Johnson, drums;
Dick Hyman, electric organ. This is the hard-swinging Ella, rather than the
gentle Ella of balladry. One of the uncontested greats, Ella punches her way
through this old classic with a backing that demonstrates the gutsy
propensities of electric organ.
GENE'S SOLO FLIGHT - Gene Krupa Quartet, with
Eddie Shu, tenor saxophone, Wendell Marshall, bass; Dave McKenna, piano. A good deal having been
said already about Gene's genius, it is well to draw attention to Shu's facile
tenor in the Lester Young tradition, and to McKenna's distinctive piano.
HANID—Coleman
Hawkins and Roy Eldridge, with Hank Jones, piano; Mickey Sheen, drums; George
Duvivier, bass. Here two giants of the swing era blow in a hard bebop groove.
Little Jazz barges in with a tense, rasped and swinging solo. Listen to the
wild thing that happens when the mute comes out. Hawk comes in low and virile
enough to sound as if he's blowing baritone. The tasteful Mr. Jones
demonstrates why he is one of the favorite pianists of Oscar Peterson, among
others. The tune, the title of which you might try reading backwards, is a
Hawkins original.
DEBUT — Oscar
Peterson, with Ray Brown, bass. This track, recorded in New York, recalls the days of the Oscar Peterson
Duo—and Canadian pianist Peterson's first tremendous impact on the U.S. public. This was the formative Oscar, and
it is fascinating to look at his roots.
LAIRD BAIRD -
Charlie Parker, with Hank Jones, piano; Max Roach, drums; Teddy Kotick, bass.
Life! From the opening phrase, the uncomplimentable Bird shows the ferocious
lust for it that he had, despite all the talk of his self-destructive-ness.
Recorded in 1953, the tune js an original whose title refers to Parker's son,
Laird.
ANITA'S BLUES —
Anita O'Day, with John Poole, drums; Bud Lavin, piano; Monty Budwig, bass.
Anita, one of the handful of great singers in jazz, dryly (and brilliantly)
reworks the timeless fabric of the blues.
SIDE B
TRIO BLUES — Art
Tatum, with Jo Jones, drums; Red Callender, bass. Callender was the favorite
bass player of the late Art Tatum. Whenever Tatum was on the West Coast,
Callender was first on call to work with him; which is how Callender, a busy
studio musician, happened to be on this date, done in January, 1956, in Hollywood. Modern jazz forerunner Tatum was in
excellent form the date this was recorded.
DOWN BEAT-Stan
Getz, with Jerry Segal, drums; Mose Allison, piano; Addison Farmer, bass.
Woody Herman tells a story about Stan Getz. When Getz joined Herman in 1946,
he played the band's book through once on the stand and, so far as Woody knows,
never looked at it again; he had it memorized. Such was—and is—the musicianship
of this remarkable tenor saxophonist. Derived from Lester Young, Getz became
the fountainhead of a whole new concept of tenor playing. Today, he is in the
odd position of being an immortal who is only 32 years old.
MAGIC—Count Basic
and his Orchestra. Personnel: Reunald Jones, Harold Baker, Thad Jones, Wendell
Culley, Joe Newman, trumpets; Benny Powell, Bill Hughes, Henry Coker,
trombones; Frank Foster, Frank Wess, Marshall Royal, Bill Graham, Charlie
Fowlkes, saxophones; Freddie Greene, guitar; Ed Jones, bass; Sonny Payne,
drums; Basic, piano. As it happens, Count Basic has been a bandleader exactly
as long as Down Beat has been in business: 25 years. (He took over the remnants
of the Bennie Moten band in 1934). Though this track was recorded in 1956, the
Basic personnel is pretty much the same today. Thus, the track represents not
only one of the most important bands in jazz history, but one that is generally
conceded to be the most exciting on the scene today.
DRUMMER'S HOLIDAY—Louis Bellson and his orchestra.
Personnel: Frank Beach, Don Fagerquist, Mel Moore, Bob Fowler, trumpets; Dick
Noel, Juan Tizol, Nick Di Mao, George Roberts, trombones; Bill Green, Buddy
Collette, Chuck Gentry, Mah-lon Clark, saxes; Geoff Clarkson, piano; Tony
Rizzi, guitar; Joe Mondragon, bass; Milt Holland, drums. One of the deftest of
technicians, Louis Bellson is one of the great big band drummers. Working with
another gifted drummer, Milt Holland, he leads — and pushes — this band (made
up mostly of top Hollywood studio muscians) into its tremendous
swing.
LESTER SWINGS
-Lester Young, with Gene Ramey, bass, Jo Jones, drums, John Lewis, piano. The
title of this tune (try humming Exactly Like You along with it) is superfluous;
when didn't Lester swing? The Father of the Cool, and perhaps the most
influential saxophonist of them all, Pres is heard here in a 1951 session that
was truly historic. Among its other points of interest: the driving playing of
John Lewis in the days when the Modern Jazz Quartet wasn't even a gleam in
John's contemplative eye.
EARLY MORNING ROCK - Johnny Hodges and orchestra. Personnel:
Ray Nance, Clark Terry, Harold Baker, trumpets; Quentin Jackson, trombone;
Jimmy Hamilton, Russell Procope, Harry Carney, Hodges, saxophones; Billy
Strayhorn, piano; Jimmy Woode, bass; Sam Woodyard, drums. This is the perfect
track to wind up this disc: Duke Ellington isn't here in the flesh, but his
spirit is all through this performance by some of his boys. Thus the track is a
tribute to the man who has contributed most over the longest time to the
growth of jazz.
POSTLUDE—Three of
the men heard on this record are gone now: Art Tatum, Charlie Parker, and
Lester Young. In the quarter century of Down Beat's existence, these were
primary innovators. There are no replacements for their individual geniuses.
But young talents
keep turning up. Perhaps a giant like Parker will be among them. One can only
guess at the direction —or directions—jazz will take. During the next 25 years,
Down Beat will go on looking for and reporting on the great talents— as it has
in the last quarter century.
“In 1985, when jazz
critic Gary Giddins was told by producer Roberta Swann that she was
thinking of putting together a modern classical ensemble, he suggested that she
help create a jazz repertory orchestra instead. With John Lewis as
the musical director, the American Jazz Orchestra had their debut concert in
1986, playing works associated with Duke Ellington, Jimmie Lunceford, Fletcher
Henderson, Count Basie, and Dizzy Gillespie. Two recordings resulted
(tributes to Ellington and Lunceford), which often found the all-star players
re-creating recorded solos. But when funding eventually ran out in the early
'90s, the American Jazz Orchestra slipped away into history.”
~ Scott Yanow, Rovi
Gary Giddins is
always doing nice things for Jazz.
His engrossing and
entertaining book Visions of Jazz: The First Century was the subject of an
earlier feature on these pages which you can locate by going here.
I also compiled an
earlier profile on John Lewis, the conductor of the American Jazz Orchestra
who, for many years, was also the musical director and pianist with the Modern
Jazz Quartet. You can locate the previously posted essay on John via this link. [Unfortunately, two of the videos in the original piece on John had to be removed because of copyright "third-party matches."]
Lastly, Roberta
Swann of the Cooper Union in New York City should be accorded major kudos and expressions
of gratitude by Jazz fans for all she did to assist and support the American
Jazz Orchestra during its all-too-brief existence.
Gary Giddins does
nice things for JazzProfiles, too, like allowing me permission to reprint the
following insert notes to the CD, The American Jazz Orchestra: Ellington
Masterpieces [East-West 7 91423-2], which is currently available as an
Mp3 download from Amazon [along with orchestra’s later recording of the music
of Jimmy Lunceford].
“From its
inception, The American Jazz Orchestra was devoted to the music of Duke
Ellington. It could hardly be otherwise. No American composer has left a
greater, more diverse body of work, or set higher standards for its continued
performance. The challenge Ellington put to posterity is twofold. There is,
first of all, the astonishing size of his catalogue, which includes popular and
art songs, suites, tone poems, a ballet and an opera, stage and Him scores, and
concertos and symphonic expansions, in addition to the thousands of short
instrumental that are the cornerstone of his art. Second, there is the medium
through which that catalogue is best known: Ellington's own recordings, surely
the finest recorded documentation of a living composer's art since Edison patented the phonograph. From 1924 until
1974, Ellington used the recording studio with prophetic and unrivaled mastery.
His records became his scores.
During the
half-century that Ellington managed to sustain his own orchestra-serving, in a
sense, as his own patron—there was little need for other orchestras to perform
his music, even though Ellington himself performed only a fraction of it in his
grueling regimen of one-nighters. Indeed, it would have been a kind of
plagiarism for another bandleader to appropriate Duke's music (though every
bandleader was profoundly influenced by it). With Ellington's passing, however,
and the passing of other great composers and arrangers of his generation, a
space opened in the life of American music. The works conceived for that
uniquely American ensemble, the big band (woodwinds, brasses, and rhythm),
cried out to be heard. The American Jazz Orchestra was conceived to help answer
that need.
Some say that no
orchestra can compete with Ellington's, that his records obviate the need for
new interpretations. As in most musical matters, Ellington anticipated the nay
savers. The variety of his numerous versions of the same pieces undermine the
whole notion of a definitive performance. Interpretation is a relatively new
idea in jazz, though it provided the sustenance for European classical music.
Perhaps if Beethoven had recorded his sonatas and symphonies, subsequent
generations would have been more circumspect in their interpretations of his
scores. But it seems doubtful—after all, Rachmaninoff, Strauss, Stravinsky,
Gershwin, and Copland are a few of the contemporary composers who did
record their own works, with no diminution of interest from other conductors.
Every year an increasing number of Ellington scores are prepared and published,
proving that as brilliant as the Ellington Orchestra was, his music has a life
beyond it. At the last of the sessions at which the American Jazz Orchestra
recorded Ellington Masterpieces, the issue was resolved for one
skeptic. A TV producer who had expressed doubt about the value of recording
Ellington stopped by to listen. After hearing a couple of takes, he half-rose
from his seat and said, "My God, this proves the music's all there in the
score!" Nesuhi Ertegun turned to him and said, "Of course, that's the
whole point."
John Lewis grew up
with the Ellington Orchestra (he was even present at the dance at which
Ellington orchestrated Chloe), and
has immersed himself in its music. Last year, he arranged several Ellington
masterpieces for The Modern Jazz Quartet's For Ellington (East-West
90926). The inaugural concert by The American Jazz Orchestra, at the Great Hall
of Cooper Union in 1986, included his performances of Cotton Tail, Concerto For
Cootie, and Jack The Bear, plus
Maurice Peress conducting "Harlem".
At the AJO's Ellington program on March 3, 1988, at which Peress conducted the
first performance of "Black, Brown & Beige" to incorporate
Ellington's final emendations, John Lewis prepared nine of the shorter works,
as well as Ellington's concert expansion of "Mood Indigo". Writing in
The New York Times, John S. Wilson
noted that The American Jazz Orchestra "has become a cohesive unit that
expresses a strong personality even when it is working within the established
outlines of Ellington's three-minute recorded arrangements." The idea for
this album was born that evening. The following November, the AJO played these
15 selections for three nights at the Blue Note. When the AJO went into the
studio a few days later, Lewis and the band were ready.
With the exception
of Rockin' In Rhythm, introduced in
1930, all of the selections on Ellington Masterpieces come from those
years which are often cited as the grandest in Ellington's career, 1940-1943.
It's impossible to gauge precisely why a particular period finds an artist in a
seeming state of grace. But in this instance some clues must be taken into
account. The early 1940s were transitional for jazz: swing was on the wain and
bebop was around the corner. Ellington had just signed a new recording contract
which guaranteed him artistic freedom. For 15 years, he had been honing and perfecting
his gifts, making of jazz (a word for which he had little use) a special world
of sui generis melodies, voicings, and structural designs. Most of his
musicians had been with him for a decade or more, and the new recruits were to
inspire him to new heights. In Billy Strayhorn, his deputy composer, arranger,
lyricist, and pianist, he found a collaborator who would eventually become his
alter ego. In the revolutionary young bassist Jimmy Blanton, he found a
virtuoso with supple time and a distinct soloist's voice. In Ben Webster, the
magisterial tenor saxophonist who had played with the band briefly in 1935, he
added one of the most original talents of the era. And in Ray Nance, the spry
cornetist, violinist, and singer who replaced Cootie Williams in 1940, he found
an irrepressible stylist who became a particular favorite with audiences. The
stage was set, and during the next few years, culminating with the presentation
of "Black, Brown & Beige", Ellington recorded a string of imperishable
masterpieces.
In the wonderfully
symmetrical Sepia Panorama, the reeds
come roaring in for the initial theme (a blues), parting for the two-measure
breaks played by John Goldsby, a young bassist with a particular feeling for
Blanton's style. The second theme is an exchange between Eddie Bert and John
Eckert, and the third finds Danny Bank emerging from the ensemble. At the
center is Loren Schoenberg, a saxophonist known for his proclivities toward
Lester Young, who in this context brings to life Ben Webster's more rugged
approach. An issue confronting every jazz repertory performance is what to do
with the original solos. Lewis opts, for the most part, to retain those solos
when they have become as well-known as the written passages. Ellington himself
had some relevant words about improvisation: "The word 'improvisation' has
great limitations, because when musicians are given solo responsibility they
already have a suggestion of a melody written for them, and so before they
begin they already know more or less what they are going to play. Anyone who
plays anything worth hearing knows what he's going to play, no matter whether
he prepares a day ahead or a beat ahead. It has to be with intent."
Billy Strayhorn's Johnny Come Lately features Jimmy
Knepper, one of the great postwar trombone stylists; another great trombonist,
Benny Powell, a 12-year veteran of The Count Basie Orchestra, is heard playing
the muted passages. Note the rhythmic meshing of the rhythm section especially
toward the end; Howard Collins is one of the last masters of the
nearly-forgotten art of rhythm guitar. On All
Too Soon, a celebrated vehicle for Johnny Hodges and Ben Webster, we hear
one of the last major figures to join the Ellington band: Norris Turney was
entrusted with the awesome responsibility of taking Hodges's place. Later,
Ellington encouraged him to write for the band and to introduce a new voice to
its palette, the flute. Knepper and Schoenberg are also heard, as is Dick Katz,
who has an uncanny flair for those skittery arpeggios that were Ellington
trademarks. Katz also comes to the fore on Ko-Ko, the ingenious blues that
originated as an episode in Ellington's unfinished opera, "Boola".
The open trombone part is played by Knepper, the muted one by Bert.
Chloe is one of the cleverest examples of the way Ellington could
adapt an inferior pop tune and make it sound like an exotic original. The soloists
are Knepper, Bill Easley (a gifted tenor saxophonist who is emerging as one of
the finest clarinetists of his generation), Bert, Goldsby, Eckert and
Schoenberg. Eckert is one of the most admired of the younger trumpet players in
New York; during a take of Chloe, Nesuhi Ertegun remarked, "To me, he's a
revelation."
Ellington wrote a
long series of portraits, from "Black Beauty" (Florence Mills) in
1928, to "Three Black Kings" (Martin Luther King) in 1974, and none
is more charming or evocative than Bojangles,
a homage to the sublime dancer, Bill Robinson. You can almost see him tapping
down a stairway, Shirley Temple in tow, during the trio episode—which,
incidentally, is played by trumpet (Eckert), trombone (Bert), and clarinet
(Easley). John Lewis took over the piano chair; Schoenberg and Easley are also
featured.
Cotton Tail, a striking variation on the standard
"I Got Rhythm" chord sequence, boasts not only a classic Ben Webster
tenor solo, but an equally famous Webster-composed chorus for the reeds. One
night, between sets at the Blue Note, Schoenberg said with some astonishment,
"You know, I feel just as creative playing Ben's solo on Cotton Tail as when I'm
improvising." He sounds it. Bank and Katz are also heard, and don't miss
the Banknote at the end. Nothing distinguished Ellington's sound more than his
use of Harry Carney's baritone sax as a leading voice in the reed section. Bank
is the AJO's bedrock.
Lewis considers Sidewalks Of New York one of Ellington's
unsung masterworks, and is surprised that it wasn't heard more, especially in
the town it celebrates. An inspired transformation of an old ditty, it is a
swinging, surprising arrangement that puts the spotlight on Easley, Katz,
Knepper, Schoenberg, Turney, and Bank. That elephant cry of a trombone figure
in the closing ensemble is by Benny Powell. Billy Strayhorn's Take The "A" Train, a perfect
example of reeds and brasses set in precision responses, was almost immediately
promoted to become the band's theme. No jazz solo is better known (or more
often performed) than the one Ray Nance played on it. When Nance left the band,
Cootie Williams (who had returned) inherited his "improvisation", and
played it verbatim night after night for 10 years. Eckert's performance is
remarkable: he's playing Nance's conception, but the interpretation is entirely
his own.
Jack The Bear, another Ellington benchmark, was the
first piece conceived as a vehicle to introduce the unique talent of Blanton,
and is no less admired for the ensemble melodies that replicate bass lines and
the crescendos played by the brasses. In addition to Goldsby, the featured
players are Katz, Easley, Virgil Jones, Bank, and Powell. Main Stem, yet
another great Ellington blues, has all the rowdy charm of the Broadways it
celebrates. The soloists are Turney, Eckert, Jones, Easley, Bert, Schoenberg,
and Knepper.
One of the most
widely-noted performances of the first AJO concert was Virgil Jones's reading
of Concerto For Cootie. He has played
it several times since, making it more and more an extension of his style and
sound. Although the melody was later turned into the popular song "Do
Nothin' Till You Hear From Me", it originated in a setting that extended
phrases beyond standard eight-bar constructions, and meshed trumpet and
ensemble in true concerto form.
Knepper, Easley,
and Jones are heard in episodes of Conga
Brava, but the key role is played by Schoenberg, in a vivid retelling of
the Webster solo. The piece was inspired by a dance craze (conga lines were
once as ubiquitous as parties) that seems especially trite when considered
beside this remarkable and rather complicated composition. Mel Lewis, perhaps
the finest big band drummer in the world, and certainly a savior of band music
in New
York
(his own orchestra recently celebrated its 23rd anniversary of Monday nights at
the Village Vanguard), defines the pulse.
When John Lewis played
the piano part on Rockin’ In Rhythm
in concert, Jim Miller of Newsweek
wrote, "Lewis remained faithful to the composer's idiom while improvising
in his own style: earthy yet elegant, bluesy, debonair, as graceful as Astaire.
Nearly 60 years old, Rockin' In Rhythm
suddenly felt brand new." The other soloists are Powell and Easley; Bank
plays the ensemble clarinet part and Bob Millikin, who shares with Marvin Stamm
lead trumpet responsibilities, plays the high note climax.
-GARY GIDDINS”
Mike Zwerin, the late
columnist about all-things-Jazz, in his Son of Miles series for
culturekiosque.com, wrote an article entitled John Lewis: A Big Gig that offered this overview of the American
Jazz Orchestra.
“Fletcher
Henderson, Jimmy Lunceford, Count Basie, Duke Ellington, Benny Goodman, Claude
Thornhill and the others developed the sound and popularized it before it
disappeared into the mists of the past described as the "big band
era."
Like horse-drawn carts and the 78 RPM, big bands tend to be remembered as
nostalgia. They are coming back, it is true, but just on Monday or Thursday
nights or like that in tiny clubs where they outnumber the guests. That ain't
exactly the idea.
In these days of instant communication, people want to know, "What have
you done for me lately?" Like last night. It's getting so we're nostalgic
for breakfast. Monday night won't do.
As part of this small but sparse renewal, the American Jazz Orchestra was
organized by a Village Voice critic, Gary Giddins, and Roberta Swann of Cooper
Union; with the composer-pianist John Lewis, creator of the Modern Jazz
Quartet, as musical director.
"Though the United States is a nation rich in symphony orchestras,
chamber groups and opera companies," Giddins stated, "it has never
produced an enduring ensemble that could present the masterworks of its
indigenous classical music." "Enduring" meaning six nights for a
one week gig. We are satisfied with so little.
Lewis and Giddins both sounded weary some summers ago, discussing the matter.
Maybe it was a two-month heat wave. Somebody forgot to turn the oven off that
summer, and the sense of purpose and humor has been hard to nourish. "It's
a lot of work, all unpaid. At least as far as I'm concerned," said Lewis.
Giddins picked up the motif: "This is the hardest thing I've ever done in
my life. I'm not getting paid for it and I hate it."
My goodness! In context, however, both complained on the reverse side of the
coin of love. "An incredibly rich and varied repertoire has been
created," Giddins also said: "Big band jazz is uniquely American. We
are trying to preserve it like a symphony orchestras tried to preserve 19th
century European music. Of course there is one big difference - the big bands
are already preserved on record. But in order to appreciate the real spirit of
this music, it has to be heard live. This is jazz music, the sound of now. And
if we want to preserve the tradition among the musicians, they must be given
the opportunity to perform it for an audience." (Every day after breakfast
at least.)
Lewis added:
"There is no replacement for live performance. The effect on the emotions
of the public is entirely different. No Matter how well it is re-mastered,
recorded music remains, in a sense, dead. It doesn't move. The purpose of this
orchestra is to preserve the golden age of large ensemble jazz and have younger
generations of musicians and listeners make it their own."
Clearly improvisation is dead when it is preserved on record. A contradiction
of terms. "Recorded jazz" is an oxymoron. Something that should be of
the moment is frozen in time.
The American Jazz Orchestra presented concerts of the music of Lunceford, Woody
Herman and Ellington. The concerts included some of the best instrumentalists
in New
York:
the trombonists Jimmy Knepper and Eddie Bert, the trumpeters Jon Faddis and
Marvin Stamm, the saxophonists Norris Turney and John Purcell and the drummer
Mel Lewis.
Each concert was preceded by a week of paid rehearsals - one of the conditions
under which Lewis agreed to be musical director. Each involved scraping
together numerous donations from $5 to $5,000 and, although Cooper Union
donated their "Great Hall" as the orchestra's home, it was never an
easy scrape.
After the American Jazz Orchestra became an established name with good reviews,
a press kit and a board of directors that includes Bill Cosby and the former New York governor, Hugh Carey, who is chairman,
Giddins tried to raise an annual budget from corporate sources to turn the
orchestra into an ongoing repertory group like subsidized symphony orchestras.
He said "I'm going after a Lee Iaccoca who loves jazz.
"I spent my entire life avoiding these kind of people," he admitted.
A quite reasonable duck: "Money people are so patronizing about jazz. If
they support classical music, they get what they consider status for their
money. Their wives have a chance to wear their expensive jewelry at Carnegie
Hall. If they give money to rock, at least their kids can wear Aerosmith
T-shirts. But jazz is a bastard art. They don't see it as improving either
their social standing or their business, and the t-shirts suck. So the basic
task is to upgrade people's perception of jazz."
Which recalls a Lenny Bruce routine. Informed that he had been booked into a
bar called "Ann's 440," he objected because it was a well-known
homosexual hangout. He wanted no part of it.
"No no," the owner replied: "We want you to change all
that."
"Gee!" exclaimed Bruce: "That's a big gig."
A big gig indeed. John Lewis has been working to improve the image of jazz for
50 years, since he played the piano with the Miles Davis "Birth of the
Cool" band in 1949. There are those who chuckle at the members of his
Modern Jazz Quartet for their three-piece pinstripe suits and solemn stage
demeanor. They have been called "pretentious." But perhaps better
than any other group, the Modern Jazz Quartet has managed to maintain the
spirit, drive and risk-taking that is essential to jazz in an atmosphere of
grand standing and status.
"I want to bring big band jazz to the concert hall, where it
belongs," Lewis said, while sipping Champagne between two grand pianos and a harpsichord
in his spacious East End Avenue living room: "But not just any
concert hall. The use of the hall is not the same as for other repertoire. The
audience is different too. You have more young people, a greater generational
mix. The size, the atmosphere, the acoustics must be suitable."
He considers Cooper Union's 900-seat Great Hall to be perfect: "We started
by putting a microphone in front of every instrument in the 'normal' way. We
thought we had to 'adjust' for the hall's acoustics. But it didn't work. We
didn't know how to fix it. Then I remembered once hearing every note Duke
Ellington's basist Jimmy Blanton played when he stood in front of the band
without any amplification.
"Another thing - the most famous use of the Great Hall was when Abraham
Lincoln opened his presidential campaign with a speech in it. He had no
microphone. Anyway, we could no longer afford all of that sound equipment with
the mixing table and the engineer. So we moved the bass out in front of the
orchestra and forgot all the microphones. And everything cleared up. The
musicians began to make their own balance instead of relying on technicians.
"Musicians today are becoming more flexible. We have no trouble finding
people who are capable of adapting to the different styles of the tradition
even though many of the younger generation have never been exposed to the
original. And, too, some of the scores and parts have been lost, we have tried
to transcribe inner voicings from recordings."
"The time is right for a reawakening to the excitement of our vernacular
classics," Giddins concluded. "The American Jazz Orchestra can
spearhead that revival and guarantee the survival of our musical heritage into
the next century."
This was all some years ago. Anyone hear about the American Jazz Orchestra
recently?”
Due to copyright
restrictions from WMG, I was unable to use a track from the American Jazz
Orchestra’s Ellington Masterpieces for the audio portion of the following
video tribute to the AJO. Instead, I’ve
substituted the Ellington Orchestra’s 1943 rendition of Conga Brava.
My thanks to Gary
Giddins, John Lewis, Roberta Swann and Cooper Union, Nesuhi Ertegun, the wonderful musicians who performed with the orchestra and all those associated with it for the gift of the
American Jazz Orchestra. Talk about a
labor of love!
"In retrospect, can you imagine the enormity of Tal’s accomplishment? Here’s someone who played a little hillbilly guitar and had no formal musical training who altered his work schedule as a sign painter so that he could listen to nightly radio broadcasts and transcribe by ear Charlie Christian guitar solos and who, after hearing pianist Art Tatum’s broadcasts, would later buy all the Art Tatum records he could lay his hands on to learn these note-by-note and play them on a guitar?! This latter feat involved a pianist whose solos were so brimming full of ideas and were played so speedily that when other pianists heard him on radio or via records for the first time, these pianists thought that they were listening to two pianists!! The scale of Tal’s achievements boggles the mind, and this from a guitarist who, shy to begin with, later became so embarrassed because he couldn’t read music that the magnitude of what he had achieved was self-effaced to a point that forced him to retire from playing music in public for long periods of time. What a way to treat genius." - The editorial staff at JazzProfiles.
Gary Giddins - "Rhythm-a-ning"
"My intuition tells me that innovation isn't this generation's fate...the neoclassicists have a task no less valuable than innovation: sustenance. [M]usicians such as Marsalis are needed to restore order, replenish melody, revitalize the beat, loot the tradition for whatever works, and expand the audience. That way we'll be all the hungrier for the next incursion of genuine avant-gardists..." (161)
Doug Ramsey of Rifftides on JazzProfiles
"Steve Cerra is the proprietor of the endlessly informative and entertaining JazzProfiles. ... Cerra excels at creating a montage of portraits and constructing them into videos that serve as musical examples of his features."
in New
York City. I heard somebody say once.
Yeah...if you can't make it
in New
York City, man, you can't make
it nowhere.
So where do people come to
scuffle? Right here.
Think you can lick it? Get to the wicket. Buy you a ticket. Go! New
York, N.Y.,
a city so nice. They had to name it twice. It may seem like a cold town,
but man. let me tell you,
it's a soul town.
It ain't a bit hard to find
someone who's lonesome or forlorn here...
But it's like findin' a
needle in a haystack to find somebody who was born here.
New York, N.Y., a somethin'
else town, all right!
East side, west side, uptown,
downtown.
There's one thing all New
York City has and that's Jazz.
A while ago, there were cats
readin' while cats played jazz behind them, but wasn't nothin' happening, so
the musicians cooked right on like they didn't even mind them.
I wrote the shortest jazz
poem ever heard.
Nothin' about lovin' and
kissin'...
One word...LISTEN!!”
- Jon Hendricks, vocalese introduction to Manhattan
With Milt Hinton’s
string bass and Charlie Persip playing brushes on snare drum in the background,
Jon speaks these poem-like lyrics on Manhattan, the opening track of George Russell’s album
New
York,
New
York[Decca DL
9116].
Each time I listen
to Jon’s vocalese, the orchestral arrangement and the individual solos on this
track, I am enthralled anew by the way all of these “moving parts” fit together
so smoothly.
It is a
magnificent piece of Jazz scoring.
Manhattanruns over 10 minutes and George uses the
space well allowing for generous solos by trombonists Bob Brookmeyer and Frank
Rehak, pianist Bill Evans, tenor saxophonist John Coltrane and trumpeter Art
Farmer to be interspersed throughout his consistently swinging arrangement.
George’s chart is
constructed in segments which serve to launch each soloist. The band then drops
out leaving the soloist accompanied only by the Milt Hinton’s walking bass line
for a chorus. The drummer joins in playing double time for the second chorus
with the band returning to provide a background until the next solo is propelled
forward.
Recorded in 1958,
the arrangements on New York, New
Yorkwere the
first extensive showcasing of George system of voicing instruments which he
termed – “The Lydian Concept of Tonal Organization.”
In his Visions
of Jazz: The First Century, Gary Giddins provides the following
background to, and description of, George Russell’s Lydian Concept of Tonal
Organization:
“Cycles and cycles
within cycles are the meat of the matter. One could argue that jazz is a music
based on cyclical motion, a strictly defined chorus, usually twelve or
thirty-two measures, repeated until a musical statement has been made. Cycles
are fomented by radical evolutionary movements, each of which contains the
seeds of its own destruction. One example: during the ferment of jazz activity
in the '40s, when modern jazz, or bebop, was born, the intoxicating harmonic
ingenuity of Charlie Parker and Dizzy Gillespie blinded sympathetic fans from
recognizing the anti-harmonic implications of George Russell's modal composition,
Cubana Be/Cubana Bop written for
Gillespie's orchestra. In a day when Thelonious Monk's clattering minor seconds
and rhythmic displacements were dismissed as the fumblings of a charlatan,
Russell's work was appreciated as something of a sui generis novelty.
Russell codified
the modal approach to harmony (using scales instead of chords) in a theoretical
treatise that he says was inspired by a casual remark the eighteen-year-old Miles
Davis made to him in 1944: “Miles said that he wanted to learn all the changes
and I reasoned that he might try to find the closest scale for every chord.’
His concept, published as the Lydian
Chromatic Concept of Tonal Organization, is based on a perfect cycle of
fifths generated by the Lydian mode, which sounds more complicated than it is.
Russell was exploring relationships between chords and scales that would foster
a fresh approach to harmony. Davis popularized those liberating ideas in
recordings like Kind of Blue, undermining the entire harmonic foundation of
bop that had inspired him and Russell in the first place.” [pp.5-6]
Richard Cook and
Brian Morton explain Russell’s achievement this way in their Penguin
Guide to Jazz on CD, 6th Ed.:
However important
Russell's theories are, they are even now not securely understood. Sometimes
falsely identified with the original Greek Lydian mode, The Lydian Chromatic Concept is not the same at all. In diatonic
terms, it represents the progression F to F on the piano's white keys; it also
confronts the diabolic tritone, the diabolus
in musica, which had haunted Western composers from Bach to Beethoven.
Russell's
conception assimilated modal writing to the extreme chromaticism of modern
music. By converting chords into scales and overlaying one scale on another, it
allowed improvisers to work in the hard-to-define area between non-tonality and
polytonality. Like all great theoreticians, Russell worked analytically rather
than synthetically, basing his ideas on how jazz actually was, not on how it
could be made to conform with traditional principles of Western harmony. Working
from within jazz's often tacit organizational principles, Russell's fundamental
concern was the relationship between formal scoring and improvisation, giving
the first the freedom of the second and, freeing the second from being
literally esoteric, 'outside' some supposed norm. [pp 1282-83].
In his Jazz
Retrospect, Max Harrison offers the following insights into Russell’s
accomplishment:
Simply, he
examined the entire harmonic resources of Western music, saw and systematized
an entirely fresh set of relationships that had always been present within the
traditional framework and which, as it were, only awaited discovery. Far from
being a constricting set of regulations, Russell's precepts made available
resources whose full possibilities, in the composer John Benson Brooks's words,
‘may take as much as a century to work out’. And according to Art Farmer,
trumpeter on many of these discs, the Lydian Concept ‘opens the doors to
countless means of melodic expression.
It also dispels
many of the don'ts and can'ts that, to various degrees, have been imposed on
the improviser through the study of traditional harmony.’ Of course, it is
necessary to remember Schoenberg's words, ‘ideas
can only be honored by one who has some of his own.’ [emphasis, mine]
That is to say
Russell offers no magic formula to transform mediocre soloists into good ones.
But the gifted improviser is not the only one to benefit. These investigations
led Russell to produce music that has strong individuality yet which is very
subtle, that teems with invention but is absolutely consistent stylistically.
And in the sheer variety of his thematic materials he surpasses all Jazz
composers except Duke Ellington. [pp. 58-59; paragraphing modified].
In Jazz
Matters: Reflections on the Music and Some Of Its Makers, Doug Ramsey
offers this essay on George’s work which he originally prepared in 1966 to air
on Jazz Review, a program that Doug
wrote, produced and broadcast on WDSU-FM and WDSU-AM in New Orleans:
“Over the next few
programs we're going to consider the recorded work of George Russell, not only
because his music is interesting, absorbing, listening, but because of his
influence on the development of jazz in the sixties. Russell's impact, I
believe, is more profound and widespread than is generally recognized, even by
many musicians. It may well develop that he is having as great an effect on the
course of jazz as any composer or arranger at work today, as important as that
of such imitated innovators as John Coltrane and Ornette Coleman.
Russell believes
that jazz must develop on its own terms, from within. He believes that to
borrow the concepts of classical music and force jazz into the mold of the
classical tradition results in something perhaps interesting, perhaps Third
Stream music, but not jazz. Faced with this conviction that jazz musicians must
look to jazz for their means of growth, Russell set about creating a framework
within which to work. In 1953 he completed his Lydian Concept of Tonal Organization.
The system is built on what he calls pan-tonality, bypassing the atonal ground
covered by modern classical composers and making great use of chromaticism.
Russell explains that pan-tonality allows the writer and the improviser to retain
the scale-based nature of the folk music in which jazz has its roots, yet have
the freedom of being in a number of tonalities at once. Hence, pan-tonality.
That's a brief and
far from complete summary of Russell's theory, on which he worked for ten
years. It's all in his book, The Lydian Chromatic Concept for Jazz
Improvisation, published by Concept Publishing Company.
Freedom within
restrictions, however broad.
Discipline.
Improvising
Russell's way demands great technical skill. Listening to his recordings, one
is struck by the virtuoso nature of the players. …. All that talk about
concepts and theories and pan-tonality and chromaticism may have led you to
expect something dry and formidable. On the contrary, there's a sense of fun
and airiness in the music. The humor is subtle and, I should add, more evident
after several hearings. …
In 1959 there was
a good deal of thought being given to the directions jazz would take and strong
indications that one important departure would be along the path of freedom.
Russell was an
invaluable guide along that path, providing the player a means of achieving
greater freedom of expression without falling into licentiousness. The means
was his Lydian Concept of Tonal Organization. It gave the improviser a
theoretical base from which to play with fewer harmonic restrictions than in be
bop. Even musicians who have never studied the theory have been influenced by
it because it is a spirit that has moved through the music. In the close
community of jazz musicians, new ideas spread rapidly. So, in a tangible sense,
this was one of the first recordings of the so-called New Thing. It is a good
demonstration of Russell's theory. But, theories aside, it is delightful
music.” [pp. 266-267 and 269].
Particularly
germane to New
York,
New
Yorkis the
following commentary by Burt Korall which served as the liner notes to the
original LP:
“New York, N. Y.... the most fascinating address.
New York, N. Y. is a world unto itself, a world of tumult and
silence, love and hate, towering buildings and tenements, big people and
small... and the gradations between.
New York, N. Y. is
a look up and live town, or a sigh, cry, die town; the big juicy apple that
tempts and magnetizes, nourishes or consumes, but is never forgotten.
New York, N. Y. has a face of concrete that menaces those who have
not found the key to her heart. And she is a woman—fickle, sometimes cold, warm
to those who know her ways. It takes time to know and love her. She is not
easy.
New York, N. Y. is
always on the move; motion is native to her torso, and whether good or bad,
profitable or not, it's there, day and night, like the beat of a tom-tom or a
heart — faster by day, slower by night; pushing, easing time along.
New York, N. Y. has many moods. She broods and all her glitter is
but a well spring for sadness. She is just as frequently happy, even frivolous,
fresh and new, depending on your view.
New York, N. Y. is a blues/dues town. She can take and forsake ...
and without conscience. In no time, her beauty can become unforgivable to
those to whom she yields nothing.
New York, N. Y., a compound of all those that live within her arms,
is liberal and bigoted, probing and disinterested. She is affected, phony, and
unstintingly real. All these things and more ...
She is rich and
poor—Sutton Place and Harlem, Madison Avenue and "The Village", Park
Avenue and "Hell's Kitchen"; Brooklyn, the Bronx and Staten Island,
too; all the boroughs and sections, streets and avenues, in sum, are New York,
N. Y. ... and contribute to her heart, body and soul.
In essence, New
York, N. Y. is people; each one important, each one in need of the other.
* * * *
New York, N. Y. is
filled with the sounds of jazz.
Jazz musicians
come pouring into New York, N. Y. ‘Let's go to the Apple, man, that's where it is,’
they cry, not realizing that the taste of it is reserved for only the equipped.
Many return to their home hamlets disappointed; some, more than a little
changed for being here.
New York, N. Y. is a cruel mistress. Bring her something new and she
is torn between a desire to understand and an inclination to resist change.
‘Prove it!’ she tauntingly says to those who come to her bearing the future in
their hands.
‘New York, N. Y. is a challenge,’ claims composer-arranger
George Russell. ‘Youth comes here to accept the challenge.’
‘I've had a
running love affair with this town since I first saw her as a child,’ he
continued. "I'd rather sink here than swim anywhere else."
Born in Cincinnati, Ohio, on June 23, 1923, Russell's first manifestations of
interest in music occurred in early adolescence. At 15, he was earning his
living as a jazz drummer in a Cincinnati night club. At 17, on scholarship at WilberforceUniversity in Ohio, he was studying music and playing with The Collegians, the college dance/jazz
band.
Shortly after his
twentieth birthday, Russell left school, joined the Benny Carter band on drums,
and came to New York.
‘I got to hear Max
Roach. He was too much,’ Russell explained. ‘Max had it all on drums. I decided
that writing was my field.’
Returning home to Cincinnati determined to learn all he could about
writing, Russell culled as much as he could from jazz writers around town. Proceeding
by the ‘trial and error’ method, the budding writer used the house band at the
old Cotton Club as a laboratory for
his work. The band would play his arrangements and compositions, allowing him
to err and correct, to progress.
Benny Carter was
the first person of significance to take an interest in Russell's writing. In
the course of one of his tours through Ohio, Carter passed through Cincinnati, heard one of Russell's compositions,
liked it. and made a request for an arrangement of it for his band.
‘It took me five
months and a trip to Chicago,’ Russell recalled in an interview with Down Beat Magazine, ‘but
I finally caught the band at a downtown theatre, and they rehearsed it. Benny
was very happy with it, and on top of that he paid me for it.’
On recommendation,
the young writer then wrote for Earl Hines and shows at the Rhumboogie and El Grotto clubs in Chicago.
In 1945, the
height of the modern revolution in jazz, everybody was talking about Parker,
Gillespie, Powell and Monk etc. and 52nd Street, the center of it all. All who
could came to New York to see and hear. Some came to learn.
George Russell
arrived in New York in 1945. He took a room on 48th Street and Sixth Avenue, four blocks from "Swing Street." He met and became closely
associated with many of the key figures creating the upheaval. Miles Davis,
Dizzy Gillespie, Charlie Parker and Max Roach, among others, were frequent
visitors at his lodgings.
‘I began writing
for Dizzy's big band,’ Russell reports. ‘I was learning. Just being on the scene
and listening helped so much.’
Unexpectedly,
illness interfered as the composer-arranger was getting his start with Dizzy's
band, and he entered the hospital. Unfortunate as illnesses are, this one
cannot be considered in a completely negative fashion. During the 16 months
spent in a hospital in the Bronx,
Russell evaluated his position, found himself in need of further education, and
began an intensive research into tonality. This resulted in the coming into
existence of elements of his Lydian
Concept of Tonal Organization, a thesis that would eventually free him,
lend the facility for full expression.
Upon discharge
from the hospital, Russell accepted an invitation to live at the home of Max
Roach. He continued his investigations, staying on nearly a year.
‘While working on
my theory,’ says Russell, ‘I lived all 'round town—East Side, West Side. John
Lewis and I roomed together for a time. He helped me to truly appreciate
traditional classical music.’
Until the Lydian
thesis was completed, Russell composed infrequently, and for short periods, at that.
He would run into problems while working within his concept that had to be
ironed out before he could proceed further. As progression was made toward his
ultimate goal of freedom within his own set of disciplines, he became more and
more the master of his materials.
Today, Russell is
not bothered by composing problems for long; he is able to make any needed
adjustments within his concept. Through extended study of music and himself,
the composer has found his way into the open.
'My Lydian concept
has changed my whole mode of life,’ Russell explained. "It took years, but
I now feel that I function logically. At last, I'm organized and ready. I
realize that music, like life, must have an inner logic. George Endrey, a
scientist friend of mine, taught me how mathematics relates to life and music.
Without him, I would never have understood logic for what it is.’
‘There are many
others to whom I owe a great deal. The Gil Evans composer conclave of 1949-50,
composed of Gil, Gerry Mulligan, John Lewis, John Carisi and myself, opened my
eyes to many things. Gil and John are special friends and have exercised more
than their share of influence upon me. Composers Alban Berg, Bela Bartok, Igor
Stravinsky and Stefan Wolpe are just a few of the others who have helped shape
my thinking.’
Reviewing his
output before completion of the Lydian
Concept of Tonal Organization in 1953, we realize that the composer had a
few fruitful periods. The results are memorable.
In 1947, he penned
Cubano Be and Cubano Bop, a two part composition that successfully combined
modern jazz and Afro-Cuban rhythms, for the Dizzy Gillespie orchestra. Bird In
Igor's Yard came off his writing desk in 1949. It was performed and recorded by
the Buddy DeFranco big band. Ezzthetic
and Odjenar were created for Lee
Konitz around the same time.
‘I was hardly
prolific,’ commented the composer. ‘Four compositions and a few arrangements
for dance bands — Shaw, Thornhill and Charlie Ventura — is not much to show for
six years, but I felt that I had to finish my thesis before I could say what I
wanted to.’
Keeping body and
soul together by working a variety of jobs in New York, N. Y., an ever evolving knowledge of self
and the importance of his work, coated his senses and dulled extraneous
pressures and annoyances.
In 1955, after two
years of experimental writing employing all the facilities of his concept,
Russell felt ready to make a statement. Jack Lewis, a jazz adventurer, provided
the recording circumstance. Reception for the composer's first statement of
policy was tremendously encouraging. Ground, at last, had been broken.
A commission to
write an original composition for the Brandeis Music Festival, which garnered
kudos for its author, followed. Offers to score albums for important jazz
artists began to trickle in. An invitation to teach at the School of Jazz in Lenox, Massachusetts was extended and accepted.
George Russell's
presence on the American musical scene is being felt; the avenues for his
talent, only beginning to present themselves.
* * * *
The extended
musical statement herein is New York, N. Y. as George Russell sees, hears and
feels it. In a sense, it is an expression of this composer's belief in the
city, the city he feels is symbolic of life and culture.
The city is drawn
in terms native to Russell's basic orientation. He is a jazz writer. His
concept was born of jazz and its needs.
It was his
intention to showcase many of the important jazz soloists on the New York scene in this program. He did so, pulling
no punches in his writing, providing an intelligent, functional, dramatic frame
for the soloists. The framework is not arbitrary, but a thematically controlled
entity from beginning to end.
New York, N. Y. is important in that a statement of depth
and scope is made. Never self conscious, though often quite impressionistic, it
is challenging to the senses, yet has the feeling of emotional completeness.
A community
project notable for the love and enthusiasm of all the participants, New
York, N. Y. moves from old jazz territories to new and back again,
breaking the barriers of tonality, presenting the jazz orchestra in a truly
modern, linear sense, yet retains the earthy taste basic to the idiom.
An American
composer, only beginning to tap his resources, is revealed.”
In order to afford
you with an interesting vehicle to watch while listening to Manhattan, the opening track on George
Russell’s New York, New York, with the help of the ace graphics team at
CerraJazz LTD and the production facilities at
StudioCerra, I have created a montage of the cover art from nearly all of the
Jazz LP’s that Decca Records released, primarily in the 1950s.
Although it had
been a major label for Jazz during The Swing Era [circa 1930-1945], Decca was
never a “major player” on the modern Jazz scene in the USA. Therefore, many of the album covers in
the video may be relatively unknown to you.
What little of value or interest it may contain, this blog is my gift to my friends.
Google Translator
Much like the Universe, the miracle of Jazz lies in its variety. Hearing Jazz played by one musician or by one group is just that; hearing Jazz played once. Jazz is infinite and only falls into two, broad categories: good Jazz and bad Jazz. We only feature the former on JazzProfiles.
George Wallington Quintet - "In Sallah" [Mose Allison]
"Gracias" by Frank Foster
John Lewis/Grand Encounter - "2 Degrees East, Three Degrees West"
Grant Green - "The Kicker"
Mulgrew Miller - "Comes Sunday"
JazzProfiles Mission Statment
A celebration of Jazz in its myriad manifestations.
The contributions
that Orrin Keepnews and Gene Lees have made to Jazz over the past fifty years are immense and go
well beyond anything that can be described in this brief introduction. Orrin’s work in recording and reissuing the
music and Gene’s in writing about it have made the world of Jazz a far richer
place because they devoted so much of their talent and creative genius to it.
Teaming up to
develop and describe this retrospective of Jeri Southern’s early recordings at
Decca is certainly an indication of the respect and admiration that Orrin and
Gene have for this member of the Jazz family, a female vocalist who was not
accorded enough of either in her lifetime.
When the likes of
Orrin Keepnews and Gene Lees have so much praise to offer about the song stylings of Jeri
Southern, the least I can do is to listen to them and to recommend that you do
so as well.
The Very Thought of You: The Decca Years, 1951-1957 [Decca GRP – 671]
“Here is a good
clear look at one of the very best singers to emerge from the Pop/Jazz/Show-tune musical world that flourished in the mid-century years. By now this era can
seem incredibly long ago and far away, but at its strongest it still retains
all of its power to charm us and move us - and to demonstrate that, in the best
of hands, this area of popular music is a true art form.
It has been my
pleasure to work on this project with Kathryn King - a long-time friend with a
solid track record of her own as a record producer, who has the considerable
added incentive of being the daughter of the artist who is heard here in
retrospect. Jeri Southern began her significant recording career with the half-dozen
years at Decca from which this CD is drawn, As we picked our way through an
extensive body of music, finding that our individual lists of preferred songs
were looking remarkably similar, it did seem best to follow chronology in a
general way, but without being excessive about it. As a result, tempo and
instrumentation and the emotional content of these songs have led to a program
that seems to pretty much set is own pace.
I knew Jeri
Southern hardly at all; I only met her after she had ended her singing career.
But I first heard her a long time ago, and have been fascinated over the years
by what I consider to be a striking example of one of the major show-business
paradoxes. This woman, a warm-voiced, sensitive, intelligent interpreter of the wonderful repertoire that a lot of
us insist on capitalizing as The Great American Song Book, had all the
qualities that I associate with two closely allied, important and consistently
undervalued fields: being a jazz singer and being what for want of a better name
is often called a cabaret singer. In Jeri's case this included the helpful fact
that she was an excellent musician [among some attributes that in my view she
shares with Carmen McRae is that she may well have been her own best
accompanist]. But like so many of the best qualified female singers of the
pre-rock days of the Fifties and early Sixties, she was typecast into a ‘pop
vocalist’ category and as a result suffered through deliberate (although
presumably quite well-intentioned) efforts to make her sound like everyone else
and concentrate on the kind of lower-level Tin Pan Alley music that only a
song-plugger or a music publisher could love.
The only two women
I can think of who entirely fought their way through that mess and emerged as
universally acknowledged major artists were obviously very strong, very tough,
and supported by even tougher friends and associates. Ella Fitzgerald, who of
course had Norman Granz as her all-American blocking back; and the totally
indomitable Peggy Lee [who was a good friend of Jeri’s and, I’m inclined to
suspect, would have been her role model if Ms. Southern had by nature been a
more hard-shelled personality]. But that was not the way it worked out for
Jeri; it should realty not be surprising to learn that her relatively early
retreat from the show biz battlefront was basically the result of her being -
to apply a phrase usually used to describe a jazz musician whose work goes
sailing way over the heads of his audience – “too hip for the room.”
Way back when I first
heard this voice, I was in Chicago visiting a World War II army buddy - it
couldn’t have been past the very beginning of the Fifties, maybe earlier. He
and his wife insisted on my listening to the laidback late night disc jockey
who was The Man of the moment, Dave Garroway, soon to become one of the very first of the star night
time (and subsequently early morning) casual television hosts. But all that lay
ahead. What Garroway was doing at that particular time was shouting the praises
of a great young locally-based singer by the name of Jeri Southern.
I became a fan at
first hearing, then admittedly cooled off as her career seemed to be going in
directions that I didn’t care for – you’ll note that we have not included one
of her most popular recordings, a folksong tear-jerker called "Scarlet
Ribbons.” Consequently, it took me much too long to become aware of some
important factors. One was that her voice remained a great instrument, and
another that she was singing a very high percentage of the right kind of songs
- merely note in passing that the
writers represented here include Rodgers and Hart [four times], Cafe Porter
[twice], Jerome Kerr [two more] and Kurt Weill.
It also seems
apparent that she was doing battle energetically and in two ways against the
kind of arrangements that were all too often in deadly vogue in those days. For
one, in a period when a singer’s worth seemed to be measured by the size of the
accompanying orchestra, she nevertheless succeeded fairly often in working on
records in much the same setting as she would appear in clubs: backed only by a
rhythm section, which on five of these numbers is led by guitarist/arranger Dave Barbour [long and closely a collaborator
with Peggy Lee). It’s a formula that at times even allows her to be the piano
player - check out the Southern solos on
Ray Noble's I HADN'T ANYONE ‘TILL YOU and her own I DON T KNOW WHERE TO TURN. And secondly, even
when the writing behind her was lush and potentially overbearing, someone --
perhaps the artist herself, or a properly- motivated manager or other
colleague - often was able to keep the
background writing under control. Or, when necessary, she seems to have been
able simply to overcome it. I refer to my own listening notes on possibly my
personal favorite in this collection, the magnificent Kurt Weill/Ira Gershwin
MY SHIP. It was a specific and private comment, not intended for publication,
but it now strikes me as quiet generally applicable to this compilation, and
indeed as a summation of the artistry of Jeri Southern. “The strings are a
matter of taste I wrote, "but it is
such a great performance of a great song.”
-0rrin
Keepnews
Remembering Jeri – Gene
Lees
"Once upon a time, America was blessed with any number of small
nightclubs that featured excellent singers singing excellent songs, and even
the' big record companies were interested in recording them. Some of the best
of them played piano, ranging from the competent to the excellent, Most of them
were women, and there was a glamour about them, superb singers such as Betty
Bennett, Irene Kral, Ethel Ennis, Marge Dodson, Lurlean Hunter, Audrey Morris,
Shirley Horn, and even regional singers, such as Kiz Harp of Dallas. Many of
them are forgotten now; Shirley Horn alone has enjoyed a resurgence.
They were
sometimes called jazz singers, although they were no such thing, or torch
singers a term I found demeaning, not to mention horrendously inaccurate. Male
singers were with equal condescension from an ignorant lay press called
crooners.
The songs they sang
were drawn from that superb classic repertoire that grew up in the United
States between roughly 1920 and the 1950s, and had any of us been equipped with
foresight, we’d have known that the era was ending, doomed by “How Much is that
Doggie in the Window?” and “Papa Loves Mambo” and “Music Music Music “even
before the rise of Bill Haley and His Comets, Elvis Presley, arid the Rolling
Stones.
Of all these
singers, one of the greatest was Jeri Southern, born Genevieve Lillian Hering
near Royal, Nebraska on August 5, 1926, the baby in a family of two boys and
three girls. Her grandfather had come from Germany in 1868, and in 1879 built a water-powered
mill on Verdigris Creek. His sons and grandsons, including Jeri’s father,
worked there. I am indebted to Jeri’s sister, Helen Meuwissen), for this
information about Jeri’s early life.
“She could play
the piano by ear when she was three, Helen said. She started studying at six. I
don t think she ever quit taking lessons. (I car confirm this Jeri was doing
some formal study of piano to the end of her life.) She went to Notre DameAcademy in Omaha, and always credited the nuns there for
her background. She took voice lessons in Omaha with Harry Cooper. It was her desire to be
a classical singer.”
Jeri also studied
classical piano in Omaha with a much beloved teacher, Karl Tunberg. But her ambitions in
the classical world evaporated one evening when she walked into a nightclub and
heard a pianist playing jazz. She loved this music, and the experience changed
her life. After high school graduation, she moved to Chicago.
She started
playing standards in clubs, and got more experience as a pianist in local Chicago big bands. Eventually, as her reputation
grew, she was advised that she could make more money if she would sing, a
standard casting for women pianists in those days: women were not supposed to
be instrumentalists, they were supposed to sing, or, just maybe, play the harp.
So she did start to sing, and accompanied herself at the piano. She abandoned
her trained operatic voice and began singing in her speaking voice, which had a
smoky sound, with a very soft enunciation and a haunting intimacy. And her
career took off.
Her greatest
popularity was in the 1950s. The first of her records I heard was YOU BETTER GO
NOW, the oldest track on this CD. I was blown
away by it: the simplicity, the exquisite lack of affectation or mannerism. She
recorded it for Decca in late 1951, just after she turned 25. She then turned
out a series of superb performances for Decca, through to the Rodgers and Hart
gems she recorded November 26, 1957: YOU'RE NEARER and NOBODY’S HEART. I met
Jeri probably two years later, in 1959. She eventually left Decca and went on
to record for other labels.
Unlike many
performers, her stage career represented a great struggle for Jeri. First, she
was extremely shy. I remember her telling me during our Chicago friendship that the first time she arrived
at a nightclub and saw her name on the marquee, it terrified her. She deeply
felt the responsibility of drawing and pleasing an audience – she was
intimidated by the look of expectation in their eyes.
There are
performers who passionately crave the audience. They will climb over
footlights, climb over the tables, do anything to claim the audience’s attention
and, I suppose, love – or the illusion of love. Jeri wasn’t like that. She
simply loved the music. The music was everything, She was almost too much a
musician, and certainty a perfectionist. Her philosophy of performing was the
diametrical opposite of Carmen McRae's, who not only wouldn't do a song the
same way twice, but probably couldn’t remember how she did it the last time.
Jeri worked on interpretation until she got it ‘right,' which is to say the way
she wanted it. She would then stick with her chosen interpretation. She was
also disinterested in scat singing. I have noticed an interesting thing about
those with the harmonic and instrumental skills to scat-sing - they often don’t
and won’t do it. Nat Cole was a classic example of this fidelity to the
original melody; so was Jeri.
As her reputation
grew, her handlers – the managers, agents, publicists, record company
executives - set out to make her into a pop star. Certainty with her Germanic
beauty, she had the basic material for it. They dressed her in fancy
gowns. They took her away from her
beloved piano and stood her in front of a microphone with some else to play for
her. Nothing could have been more diabolically designed to send her fleeing
from the spotlight. And so, like Jo
Stafford [and for the record, Greta Garbo, Doris Day, and others], she simply
quit. She walked away from the business and the discomfort it brought her.
But the
musicianship was always there, and she took to teaching. She wrote a textbook, Interpreting
Popular Music at the Keyboard. She enjoyed composing, and over the years
wrote pop songs with various partners [one of which, I Don’t Know Where to Turn is included here], and even ventured
into other genres like orchestrating film scores and writing classical songs.
I used to drop by
to visit her every once in a white at her apartment in Hollywood. Illustrating some point in a discussion
of this song or that, she would go to the piano and play and sing for me. She
simply got better throughout her life, and during these occasional private
performances, I could only shake my head and think what the world was missing.
Her piano playing in those last years was remarkable. It had grown richer
harmonically, and the tone had evolved into a dark golden sound.
She was working on
a book of piano arrangements of songs by her friend Peggy Lee, also a friend of
mine. One sunny afternoon a few years age, I telephoned Peggy. How re you
doing? I began.
‘I’m very sad,’
she said. ‘Jeri Southern died this morning.’
As I learned later,
she succumbed to double pneumonia. The date was August 4, 1991. The next day, August 5, she would have
turned sixty-five.
Once she told me
that during those Chicago years, she considered me her closest friend in the world. It is an
honor I will not forget. I truly loved Jeri, not only the singer but the person
inside who through music so diffidently allowed us glimpses into her
all-too-sensitive soul.”
-Gene Lees
Jeri Southern at
Home
"Jeri Southern was
essentially an intensely private person whose talent for music thrust her into
a public career. Since Gene Lees and Orrin Keepnews have done such a fine job of describing my
mother's public life, I thought it would be of interest to her still devoted
audience to learn something of her private life. as I knew it.
My mothers life
was unusual in a number of respects, not the least of which was the fact that a
great deal happened to her at a very early age. She started performing as a
pianist while still in her teens, moved from Nebraska to Chicago, developed a
following there, married, signed a record deal, had a baby, and had her first
great commercial success as a recording artist, all by the time she was 25. At
36 she retired from her public career. For the next 30 years her time was as
much taken up with music as it had been before, but as a teacher, a writer and
a composer - she never went back to performing.
Shortly after
recording YOU BETTER GO NOW, my mother moved from Chicago to Los Angeles, where she lived for the rest of her life.
Taking the title of one of the songs she recorded perhaps a little too closely
to heart ( Married I Can Always Get"), she married four times; three of
her husbands were musicians, one a radio der5onatity. My earliest memories are
from the house we had in Malibu, a wonderful place right on the water,
where she and I would take daily "walks' with our hyperactive Irish
Setter. The intellectual pursuits, the preoccupation, the pleasures my mother
enjoyed at the Malibu house were the ones she carried with her throughout her Life – she
loved reading, exploring the whole dimension of the mind, summoning the
restorative powers of the sun, and most of all, playing the piano.
She always
practiced classical pieces, although she never performed them. Some of her
favorite things to play were Beethoven sonatas, Grieg’s HolbergSuite, Debussy’s Images, and in later years the Brahms Intermezzi. She would also compose and improvise
at the piano. Because she suffered from what could only be described as a
crippling case of performance anxiety, she hated to be observed while she
played, and only really enjoyed herself when she thought that no one was
listening. So it was that I got in the habit of sneaking
She had the most
exquisite command of harmony, so that
when she played a tune, she would basically use it as a launching pad for an
extended improvisation which often went very far afield harmonically. Sometimes, as I sat surreptitiously
listening to these explorations of hers, I would be certain she could never
figure out how to get back to the
original key of the piece, but she
always did, and in the most spectacular way, with subtle and elegant voice
leading and chord progressions that were simply stunning. For a period of years
she also studied guitar with a fuzzy-voiced Italian whose greatest contribution
to our lives, notwithstanding the guitar lessons was probably the killer
spaghetti sauce recipe she induced him, after much cajoling, to surrender.
When she was at
home she spent a lot of time reading. She was fascinated by the work of Carl
Jung, whose ideas became an essential part of her world view. She was also very
taken with Gurdjieff, and even got interested in numerology toward the end of
her life. She found it exciting to contemplate both the innumerable possibilities
of inner space, so to speak, and the complexities of the physical world.
Another pursuit of
her life at home was listening to the work of other singers. Her perfectionism
made her a tough audience, but there were a few to whom she would return again
and again. As one can immediately discern from listening to her recordings, she
felt that the most important criterion for a great singer was a reverence for
and communication of the lyric. She was not swayed by technical brilliance; the
only singer with astonishing vocal technique whose work she enjoyed was Mel
Torme, and that was because he delivers a lyric so well. She also loved Frank
Sinatra, Nat Cole, Tony Bennett, Peggy Lee, Lucy Reed, Jackie & Roy, and the Hi-Los.
Music was really
the playing field for her entire life. And with a few important exceptions, all
of her most important relationships were with musicians, with whom she could
share her opinions, her discoveries, her delights. Though she lived in Hollywood most of her adult life, she was not involved
in that world. To say that she was reticent socially would be a mammoth
understatement.
She hated parties
and social gatherings, and had the same small circle of friends the day she
died that she’d had for decades before. But for those of us who were privileged
to be close to her, she had that rarest of gifts - acceptance. She was a
loving, supportive, non-judgmental friend and mother. She loved her family and,
in an important part of her mind and heart, she never really left Nebraska.
I still miss her
so much, but it fulfills the dream of a Lifetime to be able to put this package together, to remind the world of what a wonderful singer she was."
- Kathryn King
Jazz Writers and Critics
Over the years, the editorial staff at JazzProfiles has benefited from the knowledge and opinions of a whole host of learned and informed Jazz writers and critics. Whenever possible, we attempt to repay this debt of gratitude by featuring their work on the blog. It’s our small way of thanking those whose writings have enriched our appreciation of the music and its makers.
Big Band Jazz from St. Petersburg, Russia
The Jazz Philharmonic Orchestra's CD is now available for order through CD Baby. Just click on the image above to be redirected to the CD Baby order information.
Remembering Gene Lees: 1928-2010
"In the past few years, I have been only too aware that primary sources of jazz history, and popular-music history, are being lost to us. The great masters, the men who were there, are slowly leaving us. I do not know who said, "Whenever anyone dies, a library burns." But it is true: almost anyone's experience is worth recording, even that of the most "ordinary" person. For the great unknown terrain of human history is not what the kings and famous men did — for much, though by no means all, of this was recorded, no matter how imperfectly — but how the "common" people lived. When Leonard Feather first came to the United States from England in the late 1930s, he was able to know most of his musical heroes, including Louis Armstrong and Jelly Roll Morton. By the end of the 1940s, Leonard knew everybody of significance in jazz from the founding figures to the young iconoclasts. And when I became actively involved in the jazz world in 1959, as editor of Down Beat, most of them were still there. I met most of them, and became friends with many, especially the young Turks more or less of my own age. I have lived to see them grow old (and sometimes not grow old), and die, their voices stilled forever. And so, in recent years, I have felt impelled to do what I can to get their memories down before they are lost, leading me to write what I think of as mini-biographies of these people. This has been the central task of the Jazzletter."
What Heaven Looks Like to a Drummer
"Jazz is only what you are." - Pops
Here at JazzProfiles, we make every effort to memorialize or honor those who have given us pleasure in the music and those whose writings have taught us more about it
Alain Gerber - "Portraits En Jazz"
"En Jazz comme alleurs, le plus difficile ne se distingue pas du plus simple: c'est de jouer comme on respite." "With Jazz as with anything else, the most difficult and the easiest are one and the same; the whole thing is to play as your breath." [translation by F. Le Guilloux]
A Note of Appreciation
"I am always amazed by the fact that intelligent people with better things to do offer me their time and expertise." Martin Cruz Smith, Three Stations, p. 243.
The editorial staff at JazzProfiles echoes this sentiment and wishes to express its gratitude to all those who assist with and contribute to its efforts in hosting this blog.
Something To Think About
"Writers about jazz are often notable for an ill-concealed jealousy and a sullen conviction that they alone know anything about the subject, that it is or should be their exclusive domain." - Gene Lees
The Drums in Jazz
"The basis of Jazz has always been rhythmic. The development of jazz and its innovation from the early days of ragtime at the turn of the century to the many highly sophisticated, exciting and challenging styles of jazz that can be heard today, has always derived from that basis. In the European concert tradition, the drums serve as a noise-making device, aiming to create additional intensity or dramatic fortissimo effects. They do not effect the continuity of the music and could even be left out without creating the breakdown of a Beethoven or a Tchaikovsky symphony. In Jazz the drumbeat is the ordering principal which creates the space within which the music happens. The beat of a swinging drummer forms the basis of the musical continuity of a jazz performance." - Introduction to the Properbox set - THE ENGINE ROOM: A History of Jazz Drumming from Storyville to 52nd Street."
The Piano in Jazz
"At the turn of the century-before the age of radio, television, high-fidelity recording, and computerized video games-the piano was one of the focal points of American family life in the home. The image of Mother seated at the keyboard with the children gathered around her and Father in his pinstriped shirt and suspenders looking on proudly epitomized the American dream. White American families purchased moderately priced "uprights" at the rate of nearly 250,000 per year. In black family life the piano was one of the first major purchases made by those who could afford it. Although they were less likely than white families to own instruments, blacks frequently heard piano music in churches, which were the center of community life, or in the urban "tonks" and "juke" houses (the ancestors of the jukebox). Indeed, black pianists were largely responsible for the instrument's acceptance as "part of the family." The music they played and composed during the late 1890's, eventually known as ragtime, was a major source of the piano's popularity in the two decades that followed."
Noal Cohen - Jazz Historian and Discographer
Noal is the owner-operator of one of the best Jazz discographies out there and he's recently made some changes and additions to his website which you can checkout directly by clicking on the photo of him.
"The hardest thing about this music is getting it from the head into the hands."
"The thing you need most to play this music is concentration." - Bud Shank
Search This Blog - Type in Name of Musician to Retrieve Previous Features Posted to the Blog
Loading...
Jazz Improvisation
“In a way, the entire act of music is mind put into sound. It has to go through some sort of physical medium in order to be heard. I chose the saxophone, but the whole issue is to have such control over the instrument and over what you hear that the instrument physically doesn't get in the way of visualizing sound. Technique to me means dealing with an instrument in the most efficient manner possible so that it's no more than peripheral to expression." – Ralph Bowen
Click on the above image to be redirected to David Palmquist of Canada and Carl Hallstrom of Sweden's new site featuring Steve Voce's marvelous essays on Duke and His Men.
Typographical Mistakes [aka "typos"]
I could claim that like the age-old Chinese newspaper trick, I include typos intentionally so that you will read more closely to find them.
The fact is that I edit the entire site myself and the years are rolling by.
Please excuse any mistakes that you find on the blog and just let me know about them so that they can be corrected.
I'd appreciate it.
The "Editorial Staff" at JazzProfiles
Victor Feldman with Louis Hayes and Sam Jones
Our five-part feature on Victor Feldman is archived on AllAboutJazz. Please click on the image to be redirected to the AAJ site.
Our Your Tube Video Channel
Click on the image to visit our YouTube channel and sample our videos.
Copyright
Copyright Protection
Any and all aspects of the presentations, features and photographs as set forth on this website are protected under The Copyright Act of 1976, Title 17, Chapter 1, Section 107 and no portion of these copyrighted presentations, features and photographs may be used in any fashion without the expressed, written permission of Steven A. Cerra or the guest authors and photographers whose work appears on this site. At JazzProfiles, we frequently cite or include information from other authors or sources. When works are copyrighted, we attempt to secure permission from the author(s) or copyright owner whenever possible. If you are a copyright owner or author and believe your work is being displayed here without your express permission or consent, please contact the webmaster at JazzProfiles, and we will be happy to remove the work(s) from the site.
I started playing drums when I was 14 years old and was largely self-taught until I began taking lessons from Victor Feldman and Larry Bunker during my last year in high school. Through their connections, I ultimately found work in movie and TV soundtrack recording, doing jingles and commercials and subbing for both of them at jazz gigs in the greater L.A. area. I was a member of a quintet that won the 1962 Intercollegiate Jazz Festival held at The Lighthouse Cafe. Everyone in the group was also voted "best" on their instrument. Performed with the Ray and Leroy Anthony Big Bands and the Les and Larry Elgart Orchestras. I also worked with Anita O'Day at Ye Little Club in Beverly Hills, CA, with Juliet Prowse on a number of occasions in Las Vegas and with Frank Zappa on his 1963 film score for "The World's Greatest Sinner" which starred cult actor and director Timothy Carey.