Tuesday, February 23, 2021

A Conversation About Jazz with Mike LeDonne

 © Copyright ® Steven Cerra, copyright protected; all rights reserved.



Baritone saxophonist Ronnie Cuber calls them “New York City Cats.”


And anyone who knows Ronnie knows that he never says anything without emphasis, in this case, landing heavily on - CATS!


In Bop phraseology, the general meaning of a “cat” is someone who plays Jazz.


But in the context that Ronnie places the word - “New York City” - these are Cats who have made it on the biggest Jazz stage in the world.


And there are responsibilities that go along with being featured on this stage.


After all, the clubs in and around 52nd Street in New York city gave birth to modern Jazz. NYC was the home base of Charlie Parker, Dizzy Gillespie, Thelonious Monk, Bud Powell, Kenny Clark and Max Roach and many more innovators not only of bebop, but of the many other styles that followed it.


So there’s an expectation that Jazz musicians based in NYC and who perform there are a cut above. Not only are they required to have the superior skills to play in the modern Jazz tradition, but they are also the custodians responsible for maintaining and expanding it.


To make it in NYC, you have to be something else as a player because all the eyes of the Jazz world are on you, both domestically and internationally.


Although based in San Francisco, I fortunately worked for an international company with offices and clients in New York so over the years I was able to catch many of these “New York City Cats” in various club and concert venues.


During one of these business trips, I met the late Gerry Teekens, the owner of Criss Cross Jazz who would visit twice a year from his base in Holland to record many of the promising, young “New York City Cats.”


When discussing this subject with him one night over dinner, Gerry said to me: “The cat you need to watch out for is Mike LeDonne; he’s been there and back, almost like a return to the future kind of thing. He’s a real heavyweight and all the musicians respect him - and he really deserves it. He has it all together and he swings hard all the time”


When you read the details of Mike’s career in terms of who he has played with, then and now, as shared in the following interview, I think you’ll get a real sense of what Gerry meant by that remark. 


One thing is for certain, when you are in Mike’s company you’ll meet many of the Jazz musicians who currently fall under Ronnie Cuber’s appellation of  - “the New York City Cats.” 


And another certainty as far as I’m concerned is that Mike LeDonne could hold his own with any Jazz musician from any era, anywhere; anytime.


Thanks to an introduction formed by guitarist Peter Bernstein, I reached out to Mike and asked him if he would be up for a conversation about Jazz that would feature on my blog.


He kindly gave one of the most comprehensive and well-thought out interviews ever to appear on this page - now entering its 13th year!


I was going to amplify and annotate some additional aspects of Mike’s career in this introduction, but after reading the following, I’m sure you’ll agree that there’s no need - Mike has put it all out there.



A Conversation about Jazz with Mike LeDonne  

How and when did music first come into your life?  


My father, Mickey LeDonne, was a jazz guitarist who was very  influenced by the guitarist that played in the Nat Cole trio, Oscar  Moore. He won the Major Bowes Amateur Hour, which was a radio  version of America’s Got Talent back in the 30’s, when he was 17. His  band, “The LeDonne Trio”, made recordings and film shorts and went  on the road. The band was modelled after the Nat Cole trio but without  piano. Instead they had a vibes player that could play 4 mallets. He  never liked the road life so after getting married he settled in his home  town of Bridgeport CT. I was hearing Jazz music while still in the  womb. Our house slowly turned into a music store/teaching studio. It  was called LeDonne’s Music Box and it is where I grew up. There was  always a case of beer in the fridge in the back and plenty of guitars  and amps set up for musicians to try out and jam with. It became a  local musicians hang and I went there everyday after school and  played all the instruments, heard all the stories and listened to my  father’s records.  

What are your earliest recollections of Jazz?  


When I was 5 years old I started imitating these boogie-woogie records that my father had by ear on the piano. Even though he would  play his records that went from Louis Armstrong to Wes Montgomery  and Trane, I was more into R&B or what they called “Soul Music” like  James Brown and Aretha Franklin as a kid. My first memory of being  attracted to Jazz came one day at an outdoor party my parents had.  My father rigged up a speaker outside and he was playing Miles Davis  In Person Saturday Night at The Blackhawk. I didn’t know who Miles Davis was but the piano player stopped me dead in my tracks. That pianist was Wynton Kelly and even though I knew nothing about jazz I knew whatever he was doing was going right inside me and making me stand in front of the speaker and smile. I was probably 8 years old or so. There was another record that I loved to play whose cover really attracted me. It showed a man on a stage behind a Hammond Organ with a red spotlight on him, that man was Jimmy Smith and the record was Jimmy Smith Live at the Village Gate. The first track was I Got A Woman and it had a funky beat like the R&B I liked but I never heard anything like the sounds he was getting out of that organ. It caused me at age 10 to start fooling around on a Farfisa organ my dad had at the store which led to me getting my own Hammond B3 and Leslie speaker when I was 14.


For those readers who may not be familiar with your career, could you provide a brief overview of your background including your musical  training, groups you have worked with as a sideman and groups you  currently lead?  


Around the age of 14, I noticed these music books in my father’s store  by a man named John Mehegan. They had some nice jazz piano  arrangements for beginners in them and even some transcribed solos.  I started using them for my practicing and then we found out Mr. Mehegan lived only 20 minutes away in Westport CT so I started  weekly lessons with him and stayed with him until I was 17 and ready  to go to college.  

There weren’t any colleges that had Jazz degrees back in the early  70’s except Berklee and a Berklee degree was only accredited in  Massachusetts so I decided to add Saturday afternoon classes at  Manhattan School of Music, which was only an hour away from  Bridgeport, so I could study classical music and get prepared to  audition for a wider range of schools. Two years at MSM got me together enough to be accepted into New England Conservatory in Boston. Once there I found out they had a Jazz Department and that Jaki Byard was the piano teacher. I decided to split my time between classical studies  and jazz. This was the beginning of 4 incredible years studying with Jaki who taught me the entire history of jazz piano from James P  Johnson through Bud Powell and his own modern and innovative  concepts.  

When I moved to New York I started going to Barry Harris’s classes  and really learned about the language of bebop and there was a man  that shared space in the same studios as Barry’s class named Nicholas  “Rod” Rodriguez who wasn’t really a jazz musician but he taught piano  technique and he wound up changing my life. Nick was an old  Panamanian man who studied at Juilliard back in the 30’s to become a  classical pianist but because he was Black was never able to pursue a  career. He did however do things like sub for Jelly Roll Morton, play in  the bands of Louis Armstrong, Don Redman and Coleman Hawkins.  After all my schooling and training it was Nick that taught me how to  really play the piano.  

My career has been blessed with playing with many of the greatest  masters from a wide spectrum of jazz eras. When I first came to New  York in the late 70’s I was doing more traditional gigs with people like  Panama Francis and the Savoy Sultans, Buddy Tate and Al Grey and  Benny Goodman. I was the house pianist at the first Jazz Club in New  York City called Jimmy Ryan’s where Roy Eldridge played and all kinds  of musicians hung out and played. This was the real deal old school  New York Jazz club where we played 6 nights a week 6 hours a night.  

I later went on to start working with more Be Bop and Hard Bop  masters like Art Farmer and Clifford Jordan, Milt Jackson and Sonny  Rollins. I spent 11 years with Milt Jackson from 1988 until his death in  1999. During that same time I started playing with Benny Golson who  I still play with until this day. There were also sporadic gigs that many  other greats like Dizzy Gillespie, Stanley Turrentine, Curtis Fuller,  Jimmy Heath, Slide Hampton, Harry Sweets Edison, Clark Terry,  Donald Byrd, Cecil Payne, Bobby Hutcherson and George Coleman.  

For the first 25 years of my career I played and recorded only on piano  and then in the late 90’s a friend of mine who was playing with Jack  McDuff, and who knew I had played organ, took me up to Dudes Bar in  Harlem to hear Brother Jack. McDuff asked me to sit in and I played a  tune with the band. His reaction was enthusiastic enough to cause me  to go out and buy another B3 the next week. I got my chops back  together at a steady gig in Harlem with an unsung hero of the tenor  saxophone, Percy France, and drummer Joe Dukes who was the  drummer with McDuff the night I sat in. From there I started a gig at a  place called Smoke in New York City that was supposed to be for 5  consecutive Tuesday nights and wound up running for 20 years until  Covid shut us down. This is when I formed my Groover Quartet with  Eric Alexander, Peter Bernstein and Joe Farnsworth. I’ve also played  organ with Lou Donaldson, George Coleman and David Fathead  Newman and continue to play piano as both a sideman and a leader.    


Many conversations about Jazz invariably turn to “impressions” and  “favorites.” Okay, so let’s turn to “impressions; who were the Jazz  musicians who first impressed you and why?  


I already said how Wynton Kelly and Jimmy Smith were who attracted  to Jazz as a kid. The first jazz records I remember buying as a  teenager that were my own were McCoy Tyner's Sama Layuca and The  Greatest Hits of Herbie Hancock on Blue Note. I also had some CTI  records by Wes Montgomery, Freddie Hubbard and I remember I loved  Walking in Space by Quincy Jones. My favorite tune on it was a song called Killer Joe by Benny Golson who I would later wind up working  with for over 20 years. Ray Brown’s bass stood out to me on that record. I guess I was always attracted to the groove first, that was the main thing I needed to get into whatever music I was listening to.


Then I heard Charlie Parker, Thelonious Monk and Bud Powell and  everything changed. That became my main focus, so much so that my  nickname in college was “Bud”. I loved all kinds of Jazz but this  particular kind of Jazz seemed even deeper and I wanted to figure out  what it was all about.  

When I moved to NYC I was doing a lot of traditional gigs and I found  myself listening to older players like Earl Hines, Lester Young, a ton of  Ellington, and Nat Cole. My life here in NYC allowed me to see so many  giants and play with such a wide variety of masters my attention was  on everything and everybody. I was able to see and hear Hank Jones  play all the time which made a big impression on me and allowed me  to see how to play Be Bop but still make Benny Goodman happy. I also  discovered Cedar Walton who was another huge influence on me. I will  never forget sitting in Bradley’s as a young man and hearing Cedar  and Ron Carter burning up rhythm changes right in front of my face.  Hearing Cedar with Billie Higgins was truly a thing of beauty. As life  would have it, we wound up becoming good friends because we both  shared the bandstand with the great Milt Jackson. I always loved Milt  Jackson and his band with Cedar, Bob Cranshaw and either Billy  Higgins to Mickey Roker was my absolute ideal of what this music is all  about. To become part of that band was my ultimate dream come true.  

I guess it was the time I spent with Jaki Byard that I learned to pay  attention to all the directions in jazz throughout its history and see  them as all being equally great. I remember seeing Earl Hines play live  a couple of times and what he was playing was so unbelievable I went  on an Earl Hines binge. Same with Teddy Wilson. Hearing Tommy  Flanagan in New York showed me what music sounded like when it  came from a place of total humility and honesty. I saw Phineas  Newborn play once and I will never forget the effortless mastery he  played with. Seeing Harold Mabern and George Coleman play countless  times gave me a better understanding of the direction the music took  after Charlie Parker. They also turned out to be 2 of my dearest and  closest friends. At the end of the night on the weekend I would always  wind up at Barry Harris’s Jazz Cultural Theatre and no matter what I  had been to hear previously Barry seemed to top it and he’d do it, too, while playing a “sad” piano at 2 AM in the morning. Never made a difference  to him.  

On the organ there were many players that impressed me. In fact all  of them did. Jimmy Smith got me going and then I got heavily into  Don Patterson who bought a be bop aesthetic to the greasy organ thing. I also loved Shirley Scott and I got to lend Wild Bill Davis my  organ once. I saw Melvin Rhyne a few times and got to hang with him.  He was Milt Jackson's favorite organ player because he had the most  varied language and the most understated delivery. He was a big  inspiration to play my own ideas and not have to follow the usual path.  But I have to admit I also love the greasiest organ players out there  like Jack McDuff, Jimmy McGriff and Groove Holmes. Speaking of  “greasy,” I also got to see Charles Earland a few times in NYC and he just blew me away. Most swinging organ player I ever heard. When I first heard Larry Young he wasn’t playing swing. He was playing in the Tony Williams “Lifetime” [trio] and I was a hippie teenager and I thought it was the greatest music I ever heard. It wasn’t until later I heard “Unity'' and the recordings with Grant Green. I love everything he did. But my main  man, and the organ player that taught me to really “hear” the organ as a voice was Dr. Lonnie Smith who can do no wrong in my book.    

Staying with your impressions for a while, what comes to mind when I  mention the following Jazz musicians:  

- Louis Armstrong  

- The embodiment of this music whose every note projects its  essence.  

- Duke Ellington  

- Incomparable genius of the highest order and the most prolific  composer/arranger in the music’s history.  

- Dizzy Gillespie and Charlie Parker  

- Came along and changed everything forever. Bird and Diz have  still never been outdone.  

- Thelonious Monk  

- A unique human being that created his own ingenious music and  whose profound style of playing was highly misunderstood. He is  the creator of the harmonies that created Be Bop and one of our  greatest composers.  

- Horace Silver  

- Brought back foot tapping and finger popping by mixing the  history, the blues and bebop together and taking us on a joyride  into the future.  

- Hank Mobley  

- Unsung hero. Soulful and greasy, he left us with an incredible  body of work and many ingenious compositions.  

- Miles Davis 

- Lyrical melodic genius deeply based in the blues with a sound like a human voice. Always creating music that became the next  logical step forward and surrounding himself with musicians that  could take him there.  

- Ornette Coleman  

- Soulful Avant Garde. Opened everything up and out but kept the  blues as his foundation. Great composer.  

In 1983, Len Lyons published his The Great Jazz Pianists made up  of 27 interviews he had conducted primarily in the 1960 and 70s for  various publications. What are your impressions of the following  pianists featured in his book?  

- John Lewis  

- Elegant pianist with a beautiful sound who created something  truly unique by blending classical and jazz elements together  and, by picking just the right musicians, created one of the most  successful bands in Jazz history.  

- Dave Brubeck  

- A top composer and unsung pianist who added some different  time signatures to the pallet of jazz and helped popularize the  music.  

- Ahmad Jamal  

- A truly unique genius of the piano who stands alone in somehow  being able to resist the influence of Bud Powell. His dedication to  his own vision, and his courage to refuse to go any other way  than the way his imagination dictated, has given us a treasure  trove of deeply, substantive and beautiful music.  

- Oscar Peterson  

- OP was a friend of mine and I can say without a doubt he was a  warm and wonderful person besides being a terror on the piano.  He could roar like a beast or play the most beautiful ballads with  a touch that really defined the highest level of artistry.  

- William “Red” Garland  

- A unique stylist who mixed Texas soul with be bop. He created  his own distinct sounding block chords and swing was as natural to him as breathing.  

-- Bill Evans  

- A man who played as if his body were a natural extension of the  piano. Never a wasted note or unmusical moment. He brought  Ravel and impressionism to the table and showed us that less is  more.  

- McCoy Tyner

- A holy man and an innovator of the highest order on the level of  Bud Powell. That is to say that after McCoy Tyner jazz piano  language would be forever changed. As he said, he allowed the  creator to simply flow through him.  

- Armando “Chick” Corea  

- His recording Light As A Feather was a revelation to me as a  teenager. I had never heard Fender Rhodes played like that before and his writing was incredible. Later on I discovered Now He Sings Now He Sobs and heard a very refined and brilliant touch that sparkled with clarity on the acoustic piano. His imagination and musicality place him in a league of his own.  

- Herbie Hancock  

- An innovative genius who seems to turn everything he touches  into gold. If he only played with Miles Davis’s Quintet he would  have done enough to secure his place in jazz history but he went on to do so many other very different things and all of them were not only completely successful but broke new ground.   

- Cecil Taylor  

- I have so much respect for artists that refuse to compromise  their vision and art. Cecil Taylor had the courage to be extremely  different and found music that was truly uniquely his own. He  developed his music into a high art that is still based in the roots  of the blues and shows a link to Ellington and Strayhorn as well  as the African American composer Henry Cowell. I used to hang  out with Cecil a little back in the day and found it interesting that  his two greatest idols were Milt Jackson and Sonny Rollins.  

Switching now to Hammond B-3 Organ, another keyboard instrument  that you are closely associated with, what are your impressions of?  

- Jimmy Smith  

- The King who created all the sounds we all still use to this day. 

 - Don Patterson  

- Added a be bop aesthetic in his right hand but kept all the  grease and bluesy swing as well.  

- Jack McDuff  

- Super soulful and one of the most swinging of them all. He also  showed a be bop influence and had some of the best bands and  arrangements of all time.  

- Jimmy McGriff  

- Had his own unique kind of rhythm in his right hand. He is one of  the best exponents of what is known as the “squabbles” sound,  which was introduced by Jimmy Smith to sound like Erroll Garner, and could swing like nobody’s business. He also played  some serious funk.  

- Richard “Groove” Holmes  

- Had the best Left Hand bass lines and pedals in the business. HIs  version of Rifftide from his “Living Soul” recording was a huge  influence on me and everybody has played his arrangement of  Misty at one time or another.  

- Mel Rhyne  

- Best Right Hand lines and most unique bass lines ever.  

- Lonnie Liston Smith  

- All music all the time. Lonnie is a sound innovator and a true  master of the organ. He brings the listener inside the music with  him and lets you hear sounds you never heard before.  

- Larry Young  

- Brought the innovations of Trane and McCoy Tyner to the organ  and in doing so innovated a new way of playing. He has become  the major influence on most young organ players today.  

- Shirley Scott  

- Deeply soulful and swinging she taught me a way to play organ  with a bass player. Her style of playing chord solos is totally her  own and she had the courage to use the settings and sounds she  heard and get away from the Jimmy Smith settings.  

- Charles Earland  

- The Mighty Burner was a big influence on me. His Left Hand and  pedals rocked the house when I saw him and I loved his  repertoire. His ability to turn a pop tune into a swinging jazz tune inspired me to focus on that for The Groover Quartet.  

- Larry Goldings  

- Love Goldings and always have. He’s got a gift for improvising  that allows him to really develop his ideas in a very economical  and highly musical way. He can get music out of anything, too. I  remember when I first heard him he was playing one of the first  Hammond clones by Korg. It wasn’t a very easy instrument to  get used to and the sound was weird but I heard Larry get a lot  of music out of that thing.  

 - Joey DeFrancesco  

 - Love Joey D., he was born to play the organ. He's a totally  natural musician as seen by the ease at which he picks up other  instruments like the trumpet and plays them at a very high level.  He’s got all the organ players in him too as well as his own burning and masterful style. He can do it all.  

Why did you decide to play both piano and organ and how difficult did  you find it to make the switch from piano to organ? 

When I was a kid we always had both a piano and an organ in our house so it was only natural that I would wind up playing both. Since I’ve been playing both from my childhood, there really was no transition period. I hear and play each instrument differently.  

On your recordings for small combos, primarily quintets and sextets,  you feature a number of original compositions. Who are the composers  who primarily influenced your composing and arranging style over the  years? 

I am a Duke Ellington freak so he would be one of the first  composers/arrangers I went to school on, but there are many others  that I really love and have been influenced by. Horace Silver and Benny  Golson are two biggies. Cedar Walton is another major influence for  writing tunes that have a built in arrangement. I love the writing of  people like Hank Mobley, Donald Byrd, Kenny Dorham, Lee Morgan and  Jackie McClean. Ahmad Jamal gave me new insight about how to restructure tunes and have different sections contrasting a more open  part and one with more changes. Or alternating playing the melody  and then blowing over a vamp. McCoy Tyner is one of my favorites as  well. And of course Herbie Hancock and Wayne Shorter are two writers  that I admire immensely.  

You have had a long association with a select number of bassists and  drummers, Could you offer some commentary about what you hear in  the playing of these bassists:  

- the late, Dennis Irwin  

- Dennis was my heart. He was such a sweet man and he had the  biggest sound I’ve ever heard anyone get out of a bass. We went  all over the world together and he was so much fun to hang with. He was a brilliant guy but he approached talking about the many subjects he knew about with humor and humility. 

 - Peter Washington  

- Pete Wash is one of the nicest people I’ve ever known. A very  serious musician who is limitless in his abilities. I remember when Kenny Washington took me down to the after hours jam  session at the Blue Note to hear Peter play for the first time. We  both looked at each other and said “he’s in there!”.  

- Christian McBride  

- I’ve known McBride since he was a teenager. I used to use him  on trio gigs around NYC. We did a world tour together for Phillip  Morris when they used to put together these first class tours. We  went from NYC to Hong Kong; over almost 2 months together.  He’s always been a phenomenal player and a very giving and  positive person who has focused on the blues, having a huge  sound and swinging hard. It’s been amazing seeing him ascend  to dizzying heights in the music world. It couldn’t have happened  to a nicer guy. I still see him as the teenager I met many years  ago.  

- John Webber  

- Webs is truly a badass. He’s one of my oldest and dearest  friends. He’s always been a man of few words but put that bass  in his hands and he’s a beast. Huge sound and always swinging.  One of his main influences was the great Bob Cranshaw who is  someone I also spent a lot of time playing with and who knew  where to put offbeats and fills. John is one of the greatest.  

And some commentary about what you hear in the playing of these  drummers:  

- Joe Farnsworth  

- Joe has risen to the top of the heap and can play any kind of  music but his forte is swing. He’s also got great technique but  never flaunts it and prefers to fire up in a relaxed way that  allows him to play blazing tempos with ease. He is always in  service to the music and has keen musical sensibilities in terms  of reacting to and highlighting what’s happening around him.  He’s also an exciting soloist who’s not afraid to try unique  sounds.  

- Lewis Nash  

- Extremely musical drummer. Nash and I go way back and I have  always loved playing with him because he not only has a great  groove but he has a sixth sense about playing just the right  compliment to whatever the soloist is playing. I’ve had so many  moments while playing with him he’s playing the same thing I  am at the exact moment I play it. It’s like he’s telepathic or  something. And he’s one of the nicest people I know but he gets  downright mean when he explodes into his solos. 

- Kenny Washington  

- Wash is truly my brother. We’ve been through thick and thin  together. He was the best man at my wedding and I was the  best man at his. We know each other like books and no one  knows more about this music than he does. He’s got an  encyclopedic knowledge of the tens of thousands of records he  owns and he can sing you the solos from them in the key they’re  in on the record. He’s a drummer with photographic memory and  perfect pitch. His soloing is a thing of true beauty, I’ve rarely  heard anyone put together the different elements of a drum solo  in such a clear and profoundly musical way. He makes the drums  into a melodic instrument. His love in life is to swing and play  some “grease”. No one in the world can do what he does.


Could you please talk about your impressions of the following  musicians you have recorded with:  

- Tom Harrell [trumpet]  

- The word genius gets tossed around a lot these days but I think  Tom is the real thing.  

- Ryan Kisor [trumpet]  

- Incredible player who is at the top level as a soloist and could  also easily play lead in any big band.  

- Jeremy Pelt [trumpet]  

- Beautiful sound and soulful player who really knows the history  and is comfortable in any setting.  

- John Gordon [alto sax]  

- One of the best alto players I’ve ever heard who has a big heart  and soul that comes through in every note.  

- Joshua Redman [tenor sax]  

- Wonderful down to earth human being and one of the best  players of his generation. Josh has a very personal sound and  style that is at once faithful to the history and pushing forward  into the future.  

- Eric Alexander [tenor sax]  

- One of the smartest guys I know with a very unique personality  and playing style all his own. He has developed his own language  on the horn but never loses his roots in the most soulful players  of all time.  

- Gary Smulyan [baritone sax]  

- I’m proud to say his recording debut was on my first date as a  leader Bout Time. Gary has established himself as a true giant

of the Baritone Sax who has a sound that can knock you over  and a mind that eats up chord changes like Pac Man.  

- Peter Bernstein [guitar]  

- I feel lucky to have witnessed his ascent in developing his own  very distinctive style that is based on the classic sounds of jazz  guitar but is not bound by it. His style has become very  influential among young guitar players. He always brings his A  game and he’s not afraid to play some blues.  

- Steve Nelson [vibraphone]  

- Steve has always had a very warm and soulful sound on both  Vibes and Marimba. More than anyone I know his playing is a  natural extension of who and what he is as a human being. That  is to say there is no pretense or flash in him as a person or as a  player, he couldn’t play a phoney note if he tried. His style of  playing and writing are very personal and unique.  

The Groover Quartet is your most recent group. Who are the other  players in the group and why did you form it?  


The Groover Quartet grew organically (pardon the pun) out of a steady gig on Tuesday nights at Smoke Jazz Club in NYC. I had already been  playing piano gigs with Eric Alexander and Joe Farnsworth for several years, as well as doing a few organ gigs with them and Peter Bernstein, so when the gig came about at Smoke it made sense to do it with them. At first the owner Paul Stache told me he wanted to make it a gig for a number of organ players so he gave me the first 5 weeks, but when the 5 weeks was over he didn’t want us to stop. 20 years later we’re still there.  

I should add that Paul was a huge fan of The Mighty Burner, Charles  Earland, an organ giant that Eric had spent several years with. In fact,  it was at a memorial Paul held at Smoke after Earland’s death where  he heard me play the organ for the first time. My friend, and trumpet player extraordinaire Jim Rotondi, is the one that called me and asked me to come up there with him and play a tune. I always loved Charles  Earland so it was an honors for me to do it and I remember we played  an arrangement of Horace Silver’s Blowin The Blues Away that Eric  and Jim used to play with The Mighty Burner.  

As I got into having to play every week I began to see that the crowd  was largely made up of students from Columbia University which is  located close by. I had the feeling they would not relate to us playing  old standards like All The Things You Are so I took a page from Charles  Earland’s book and began arranging R&B tunes so that they swung and  became good vehicles for soloing. With the luxury of a steady gig I was able to bring in all kinds of arrangements and original tunes and  try them out in front of people to see what worked and what didn’t.  


Week by week our repertoire grew and eventually we began recording  for Savant Records. At first they were under my name alone but I  wrote a tune for the late great drummer Tony Reedus, who had been  playing with us for a while and suddenly passed away, called “The  Groover”. That was also the title track from our first #1 CD. After that  we kept the name The Groover Quartet. People think it’s a nickname of  mine, and it has become one after all these years, but it didn’t start  out that way. Since that recording I’ve been digging into the tunes of  Earth Wind and Fire, The Spinners, Steve Wonder, and all the R&B I  grew up on and turning it into a book of music that is now the size of  an old Manhattan Yellow Pages. We’ve had several #1 CD’s, have  traveled all over the world together, and people come from all over the  world to catch us on Tuesday nights at Smoke.  

Switching to the subject of “favorites:” - What are some of your  favorite Jazz recordings? 

Impossible to list because there are so many.  

Even though this list is going to be long there is plenty that will be left  out.  


I’d have to start with Miles Davis in Person Live at The BlackHawk. I’d  also add Miles Davis Relaxin (recorded the same day and year of my  birth 10/26/1956) And the usuals by Miles, Kind Of Blue, Live at the  Plugged Nickel, All the Columbia stuff, Four and More, Milestones,  Walkin, Live at Newport, and all the Gil Evans stuff.  

Charlie Parker with Fats Navarro and Bud Powell One Night at  Birdland as well as Bird with Strings and Bird is Free.  

Bud Powell The Amazing Bud Powell on Blue Note and The Genius Of  Bud Powell volumes 1&2 on Verve.  

Thelonious Monk Genius Of Modern Music Blue Note, Live at Town  Hall, With John Coltrane, Plays Duke Ellington  

Sonny Rollins - On Impulse, Blue Note Vol 1, Way Out West, Jazz  Classics, Plays Bird, Live at the Village Vanguard, Saxophone Colossus,  Tenor Madness  

Kenny Dorham - Stage West, Showboat, Quiet Kenny, Whistle Stop Lester Young with Nat Cole and Buddy Rich, Pres, and Decca Basie.  Everything by Duke Ellington including his early dates on Victor, his  trio recording Piano Reflections and all of his Columbia Masterpieces  recordings like Piano in the Background.  

Bill Evans Everybody Digs and Portrait in Jazz. Also the live  recordings from the end of his life called Last Waltz and Live at the  Village Vanguard.

All the Wynton Kelly on Vee Jay like Kelly at Midnight and Kelly  Great.  

Hank Jones Solo Piano 1956 and Tip Toe Tap-dance plus all his Savoy  recordings with Kenny Clarke.  

Milt Jackson Bags and Wes, Live at Koseinenkin Hall and Bags and  Trane, Ballad Artistry  

Cannonball Adderley Somethin’ Else, and all the Quintet recordings  especially Live in New York at the Vanguard.  

Cedar Walton trio recordings on Red Records, Live at the Pit Inn,  Eastern Rebellion with George Coleman  

Red Garland In Bluesville, Reds Piano, Live at the Prelude, Soul  Burnin.  

Herbie Hancock, Speak Like A Child, My Point Of View, Maiden  Voyage, Inventions and Dimensions, Dedication  

Chick Corea, Light As A Feather, Tones For Jones Bones , Now He  Sings Now He Sobs.  

Bobby Hutcherson, Total Eclipse, Oblique, The Kicker, Solo/Quartet,  McCoy Tyner The Real McCoy, Time For Tyner, Counterpoint,  Inception, Reaching Forth, Sama Luyaca, Together, Atlantis  

Wayne Shorter - Speak No Evil, Night Dreamer, JuJu, High Life  

John Coltrane Blue Trane, Tenor Madness, Giant Steps, Coltrane Jazz,  All the Impulse stuff like Ballads, With Duke Ellington, Coltrane, A Love  Supreme, Crescent, Live in Europe.  

Hank Mobley all the Blue note recordings like Workout, Another  Workout, Soul Station, Straight No Filter, Far Away Lands  

Lee Morgan - Candy, Charisma, Delightful Lee, The Procrastinator,  Live at the Lighthouse, Sonic Boom, Search For A New Land  

Jackie McClean Consequence, It’s Time, Jackie McClean Quintet on  Blue Note, Jackknife  

Donald Byrd Byrd’s Words, Off To The Races, Royal Flush,  Blackjack,Fancy Free  

Art Blakey -Live At Birdland, Three Blind Mice, Indestructible, Like  Someone In Love, Ugetsu, Moanin,  

Horace Silver - And the Jazz Messengers, Six Pieces Of Silver,  Stylings, Further Explorations, Finger Poppin, Blowin the Blues Away,  Horace Scope, Silver’s Serenade, Song For My Father, Tokyo Blues, In  Pursuit If The 27th Man, Jody Grind,  

Stanley Turrentine - Easy Walker, Sugar, Chip Off The Old Block, Mr  Natural, Let It Go  

Ahmad Jamal But Not For Me, Live At The Pershing, Chamber Jazz,  Happy Moods, Count Em 88, Awakening, Blue Moon, It’s Magic, I Hear  A Rhapsody 

Jimmy Smith The Sermon, The Boss, Dynamic Duo with Wes  Montgomery, Live at The Village Gate, Off The Top, Midnight Special,  Back at the Chicken Shack.  

Don Patterson Mellow Soul, The Boss Men with Sonny Stitt, Brothers  4, Soul Happening  

Charles Earland Black Talk, Front Burner, Blowin The Blues Away,  Leaving This Planet  

Shirley Scott Queen of The Organ, Soul Duo, Hip Soul, Hip Twist, Soul  Shouting, Blue Flames  

Jack McDuff - LIVE!, Tough Duff, The HoneyDripper  

Jimmy McGriff - The Worm, Bag Full Of Soul, Soul Survivor  Groove Holmes - Misty, On Basie’s Bandstand, Living Soul  

Wes Montgomery - Dynamic Duo, Live at The Half Note, Guitar On  The Go, Boss Guitar, Movin Along, Bags Meets Wes, Portrait of Wes,  Bumpin, Tequila, Road Song, Down Here On The Ground, Further  Adventures  

Freddie Hubbard - Red Clay, Ready For Freddie, Body And Soul, Blue  Spirits, Backlash, The Hub of Hubbard, Hubcap, Hot Horn, Keep Your  Soul Together, First Light  

Woody Shaw - Little Red’s Fantasy, Rosewood, United, Casandranite  Grant Green - Grant Stand, Matador, Street Of Dreams, Iron City  

Art Tatum - Solo Masterpieces, 20th Century Genius, Private Session.  Oscar Peterson - Duke Ellington Songbook, Affinity, We Take  Requests, West Side Story, Anything on the MPS label.  

Count Basie - On Decca, Breakfast Dance Barbecue, Chairman Of The  Board, Atomic Basie, Live in London  

Sonny Stitt And the New Yorkers, Sits In with the Oscar Peterson Trio,  Stitt meets Brother Jack McDuff, Nightcrawler, Now,  

Lucky Thompson - Everything with Milt Jackson like Skyline, Plays  Jerome Kern, Offering, Sonny Lester Collection.  

Barry Harris - Indiana, Bulls Eye, Luminescence  

Max Roach - 3/4 Time, +4, Plays Charlie Parker  

Earl Hines - 57 Varieties, Plays Duke Ellington  


When Mike LeDonne is away from music, where will we find him and  what will he be doing? 


My life outside of music has become very busy for 2 reasons. I’m  raising a wonderful disabled daughter named Mary and I started a non  profit to benefit the entire community she is part of called Disability  Pride NYC. Being someone who is used to creating things that have  never existed before I decided to create a parade called the Disability  Pride NYC Parade. The idea was to raise awareness, promote inclusion  and increase the visibility of a community that has been shoved in the  shadows for much too long. It’s both a fun day of celebration and pride  and a civil rights march. We had our first parade in 2015 and have  made it an annual event here in NYC that attracts 10,000 people. It’s a  ton of work but it is so worth it when you see 10,000 disabled people  coming down Broadway struttin’ their stuff and feeling powerful. When  large numbers of people like that come together everyone takes notice  including politicians who realize this is a huge voting block of people they need to take seriously. If people are interested in checking it out  please visit our website at www.disabilitypridenyc.org.  

Obviously, the pandemic has made future planning challenging at best,  but when things do calm down a bit, what do you hope to be doing  musically.

  

I want to do what I’ve been doing which is to keep improving as a  musician and put a little swing out into the world because I feel it’s  been getting lost. I love to hit pockets and that’s what I’ll be doing  until the day I die. 


Sunday, February 21, 2021

The Tony Williams Lifetime / Emergency

Tony Williams: Two Decades of Drum Inspiration - by Paul deBarros

 © Copyright ® Steven Cerra, copyright protected; all rights reserved.


The editorial staff at JazzProfiles has previously written quite extensively about the late drummer Tony Williams [1945-1997] and you can locate a combined posting of these features by going here.


We recently came across the following interview that Paul deBarros did with Tony that was published in the November 1983 edition of Downbeat and we thought we would bring it up on these pages to have more of Tony’s views on drumming and music available in his own words on the blog.


Never one to be at a loss for words or timid about expressing his opinions, his brashness, assertiveness, and candor - none of which is meant pejoratively - are also reflected in his musical “personality.” 


After all, as Pops [Louis Armstrong] often stated: “Jazz is what you are.” Put another way, Tony’s style of drumming is bold, forceful and colorful so why would we expect him to be any less so in an interview?


“Tony Williams erupted onto the jazz scene in 1963, a 17-year-old prodigy with a full-blown, volcanic style of drumming that would blow hard-bop  lustiness  out the door. Williams' arrival was hailed with a great deal of fanfare. The week he came with Miles Davis to San Francisco's Jazz Workshop,  the   club   temporarily  relinquished its liquor license so the underage genius could play. I remember, because it was the first time I was allowed in as well. Williams played the drums that week at a level of energy and activity — not to mention volume — that was not only exciting, but liberating. Whirling from crash to ride to slack hi-hat, now pummeling, now tickling, now coaxing, he machine-gunned the bass drum, pulled low-pitched "pows" from the toms and jagged bursts from the snare as if his legs and arms were connected to four separate torsos. His complex, distinct style, which owed a lot to the floating time of Roy Haynes and thrust of Elvin Jones (Sunny Murray's unbridled freestyle was a simultaneous development rather than an influence), suggested that jazz drumming might exist as an adjunct to, as well as a support for, the rest of the band.


Williams stayed with Davis five years. In 1968, like Herbie Hancock and Ron Carter before him, Williams left Miles, smelling rock & roll in the air. Joining forces with keyboard man Larry Young and British guitarist John McLaughlin (whom Tony discovered, but Miles snatched into the recording studio first, for In a Silent Way), the drummer recorded a groundbreaking jazz-fusion trio album, Emergency, for Polydor (recently reissued as Once In a Lifetime, Verve), of psychedelic fervor and volume. For a while it looked as if Tony Williams was going to take the electric '70s by storm, as he had the acoustic '60s.


But it didn't turn out that way. At Polydor he suffered poor management, poor promotion and poor sales. Fans who had exhaled "far out" for Emergency dumped Turn It Over and Ego into the used-record bins. The critics lambasted him, crying, "Sellout." Williams, for all his bravado a vulnerable fellow, retreated, confused. From 1973 to '75 and again from 1976 to '79, he vanished as a leader. When he did come back, with Columbia, it was with the crisp, straight-ahead rock of Believe It, pumped full of hot air by a disco-ing promotional department. Jazz fans shook their heads, wondering what had happened to their young hero. After an exhibitionist tour de force, Joy of Flying, in 1979, on which he amassed everyone from Cecil Taylor to Tom Scott, Columbia dropped Williams in the middle of a seven-record contract. More than ever, he began to look like the Orson Welles of jazz, burst-ing into the world with creative energy only to make a long, agonizing finish. One critic, Valerie Wilmer, even went so far as to dismiss him as a showman.


But Wilmer, and others, weren't really paying attention. While it was true that Tony Williams hadn't come up with any project matching the creative vision of Emergency or the late-'60s Miles quintet (hard acts to follow), he had certainly held his ground, which is considerable. He is every bit as good a jazz drummer as he was 20 years ago, as his recent performance in Seattle with V.S.O.P. II attested. Besides, none of the other great jazz drummers — Max Roach, Art Blakey, Elvin Jones — has altered his style after its initial breakthrough. Williams' work in rock has been a mighty influence, right down to the current work of Journey's Steve Smith.


As for integrity, Williams has this to say to his critics: "People have this thing that if you like pop music, it's because of the money. My career will tell you I've never done anything for the money. Writers and critics and people in the jazz world think you cannot possibly like the Police because of the music, which is absurd. I do the things I do because they excite me, and the rest is a load of rubbish."


Williams continues to tour both in rock and jazz situations. In 1980, he played Europe with young Portland, Ore., fusion keyboardist Tom Grant and Missing Persons bassist Pat O'Hearn; in 1981 and '83 he toured with V.S.O.P. He plays on one track of Grant's Columbia album You Hardly Know Me, and on several with Wynton Marsalis, who replaced Freddie Hubbard in V.S.O.P.


In 1977, the drummer moved from New York to Marin County, north of San Francisco, where he lives in a country home with his girlfriend. Three days a week he drives to UC Berkeley, where he is studying classical composition with Robert Greenberg. When he is not composing fugues or studying counterpoint ("It's a mountain of work," says Williams), he is in the studio in San Francisco or busy catching up on some of the things he missed growing up a superstar: playing tennis, swimming, learning German and driving his Ferrari. Williams says the move to California has revitalized his creative life and helped him to get past the tangled 1970s.


Paul de Barros: You completely changed jazz drumming in the 1960s. Were you consciously aware at any certain point that you were doing something new?


Tony Williams: Not really. I guess I was aware that I was playing differently, but it was more of a thing that I was aware of a need, like if you see a hole, you think you can fill it. There were certain things that guys were not playing that I said, "Why not? Why can't you do this?"


de Barros: How important was Alan Dawson, your teacher in Boston, in your development of independence in all four limbs?


Williams: What I got basically from Alan was clarity. He had a lot of independence, but so did other people. I get this question about independence a lot, even from drummers, but they can't even be clear about their ideas. I mean, you hear them play something, and you say, "What was it that he played?" Or if they hear themselves back on tape, they say they thought they played good, but that it didn’t sound like that. So the idea is that when you play something for it to sound like what you intended, not to have a "maybe" kind of sound. So that's what I got from Alan, the idea that you have to play clearly


de Barros: Were you thrilled to be part of the Miles band in the '60s?


Williams: Well, when you're doing things it's hard to say, "Oh gee, this is going to be real historical sometime." I mean, you don't do that; you just go to the sessions, and 10 or 20 years later people are telling you that it was important. When you're doing it, you can't really feel that way.


de Barros: What is your relationship with Miles now?


Williams: Very friendly. I saw him this summer. I haven't heard the new albums. but when we played opposite him, I heard bits and pieces of the band, and Miles was sounding good. He's been practicing. I liked Al Foster [Miles' drummer] years ago, when I was with Miles.


de Barros: You've played with a lot of illustrious musicians. Being a drummer, you have to adapt to each one differently. Let's talk about some of them, say, beginning with Sonny Rollins and McCoy Tyner.


Williams: Sonny has a very loose attitude about things — the time, the whole situation. With McCoy I always felt like I was getting in his way, or that it never jelled. I felt inadequate. Actually, with both Sonny and McCoy, it's like you're playing this thing, and they're going to be on top of it.


de Barros: How about John McLaughlin and Alan Holdsworth?


Williams: Completely different. John is more rhythm oriented. He plays right with you, on the beat. He'll play accents with you. Even while he's soloing, he'll drop back and play things that are in the rhythm. Alan is less help, With Alan it’s like he's standing somewhere and he's just playing, no matter what the rhythm is,


de Barros: Wynton Marsalis and Freddie Hubbard?


Williams: Freddie plays the same kind of solo all the time. I get the feeling that if Freddie doesn't get to a climax in his solos, and people really hear it, he gets disappointed. With Wynton it's always different. I don't know what he's going to play. It's always stimulating.


de Barros: I gather you think Wynton Marsalis' manifesto about only playing jazz — and not funk or rock — is not that important?


Williams: He thinks it's an important attitude. That's what counts.


de Barros: A lot of fans and critics still find a contradiction in your playing what they see as oversimplified rock as well as the kind of complex jazz you played with Miles and you play now with V.S.O.P. II. What 's your reaction to that?


Williams: Well, first of all, just because it's jazz, doesn't mean it's going to be more complex. I've played with different people in jazz where it was just what you'd call very sweet music. No type of music, just because it's a certain kind of music, is all good. A lot of rock & roll is not happening. And a lot of so-called jazz,  and the people who play it, are not happening. Complexity is not the attraction for me, anyway—it's the feeling of the music, the feeling generated on the bandstand.  So playing in a heavy rock situation can be as satisfying as anything else. If I'm playing just a backbeat with an electric bass and a guitar, when it comes together, it's really a great feeling.


de Barros: You were quoted in Rolling Stone praising the drummer in the Ramones. Were you serious?


Williams: I don't remember the occasion, but I do like that kind of drumming, like Keith Moon, any drumming where you have to hit the drum hard; that's why I like rock & roll drumming.


de Barros: Sometimes so much of that music seems very insensitive.


Williams: It depends on what you're saying the Ramones are supposed to be sensitive to. Just because it's jazz doesn't mean it's going to be sensitive to. You're trying to evoke a whole other type of feeling with the Ramones. When I drive through different cities and I look up in the Airport Hilton and I see the sign that says, "Tonight in the lounge, 'live jazz'" — I mean, what the hell does that mean? I'm not saying everybody's like this, but I can see a tinge of people saying, "This is the only way it was in 1950, and we're going to keep it that way, whether the music is vital or not, whether or not what we end up playing sounds filled with cobwebs." When John Coltrane was alive, there were all kinds of people who put him down. But these same people will now raise his name as some sort of banner to wave in people's faces to say, "How come you're not like this?" These same people. That's the hypocrisy, and I find it very tedious.


de Barros: How important is technique?


Williams: You've got to learn to play the instrument before you can have your own style. You have to practice. The rudiments are very important. Before I left home, I tried to play exactly like Max Roach, exactly like Art Blakey, exactly like Philly Joe Jones, and exactly like Roy Haynes. That's the way to learn the instrument. A lot of people don't do that. There are guys who have a drum set for two years and say they've got their own "style."


de Barros: How can we prevent those kinds of guys from taking; up more room than they deserve?


Williams: (Laughing.) Well, we could pass a law.


de Barros: The Bad Drummer Ordinance?


Williams: Exactly. Anyone who does not study is shot! Seriously, though, it's a big responsibility when you play the drums, and a lot of guys don't want the responsibility, but they want to play the drums. The drummer is playing all the time. You can have a terrible band and a great drummer, and you've got a good band; but you could have great horn players, and if the drummer and the bass player aren't happening, you've got a terrible band.


de Barros: Is tuning important?


Williams: Yes, I hear drummers that have maybe 12 drums that all sound the same. If you closed your eyes, you wouldn't know where they were on the set. Or else you'll have guys where each drum sounds like it's from a different set. It's important that the drum set sounds like one instrument. Like, if you have a piano, you wouldn't want the C to sound like a Rhodes, the D to sound like a Farfisa, the E to sound like a Prophet. A keyboard is a uniform system; a trumpet is a uniform system ... drummers are out to lunch. On some of my drums, the bottom head is tighter than the top head. On other drums they're about the same. And on the bass drum the front head is looser than the batter side.


de Barros: Have you tried electronic drums?


Williams: Yeah! I tried the Simmons. The separation you get on tape is great. The programmability, the sound, the sequencing... it's another thing to do that seems very interesting. I have a DMX (electronic, programmable drum machine by Oberheim] at home.


de Barros: Will electronic drums be part of what you're doing in the studio?


Williams: Oh yeah, they already are.


de Barros: Can you say anything more about what direction your music is going?


Williams: The popular direction. I like MTV. I like the Police, Missing Persons, Laurie Anderson. I performed with her on a San Francisco date. It was great, I love the new Bowie album. Prince. I like the idea of writing lyrics, of putting images with words that evoke a scene on top of the music. I like Herbie's new album - [Herbie Hancock, Future Shock, Columbia 38814]. It's really happening.


de Barros: Are you interested in making a video yourself?


Williams: Sure. Growing up in this country, watching TV and movies, everyone would like to make a movie. It's a new thing to do. You know writers want to be painters; screenwriters want to be directors. Musicians want to make movies. Doing a project and having a lot of people like it and maybe listen to it on the radio, that appeals to me. What I'm trying to do is something that captures a lot of people's imaginations. If the result is I'm more famous, fine. But it's not like I'm after being a pop star.

dd Barros: You've said in the past that jazz should be popular, not an elitist art form. But isn't it about time Americans claimed jazz as their art form and started recognizing it with the kind of respect they give to European music?


Williams: That's a fine thought, but how much is that really going to do for musicians? I don't think society really recognizes classical music, anyway. It's all patronage, and grants, a certain class of people. Jazz was originally the music of the people in the streets and not in concert halls, so when you lose that, you suffer the consequences. There's nothing wrong with jazz being an art form, but it has a certain roughness and vitality and unexpectedness that's important. I guess I'm old-fashioned.”